Will A Strong 2017 Carry Over Into 2018?

Updated on

Key Takeaways

  • 2017 was a remarkable record-breaking year for stocks.
  • 2018 is off to a very strong start, with stocks up all four trading days and the S&P 500 already 2.6% higher year to date.
  • Given clarity on the new tax law, we summarize our equity views for 2018.

Get The Timeless Reading eBook in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Timeless Reading in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

We close the book on a solid 2017 for U.S. stocks while tipping our caps to a strong start to 2018. Today’s Weekly Market Commentary will provide a high-level performance recap for 2017 that we hope will be helpful for year-end client conversations, in addition to a summary of our equity market views for 2018 following passage of the new tax law.

A Quick Look Back At 2017

2017 was truly a remarkable year for the U.S. stock market with record breaking abound. The S&P 500 Index produced 12 positive monthly returns for the first year ever. The Dow Jones Industrials Average produced 71 record highs — its highest total ever. And the year proved to be one of the least volatile in the history of the VIX Index, with some of the lowest volatility readings ever and without so much as even a 3% pullback, despite significant geopolitical uncertainty worldwide.

The strong year for stocks was driven by several factors but we attribute the gains primarily to the following:

  • Synchronized global economic expansion. U.S. economic growth picked up some speed as 2017 progressed, helping support gains in U.S. stocks. But equally as important was the breadth of growth globally. As 2017 ended, all Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries had manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Indexes over 50 and, impressively, more than 80% of them rose year over year in the latest reported month (November).
  • Global earnings rebound. The S&P 500 is on track to produce a 10% increase in profits in 2017 based on current consensus estimates from Thomson and FactSet. Technology and emerging market equities were big beneficiaries of earnings-driven gains as each rallied nearly 40% and saw strong earnings increases.
  • Passage of new tax law. Despite skeptics, President Trump and congressional Republicans delivered tax reform before Christmas. The anticipation, eventual passage, and expected boost to corporate profits from the tax bill all helped stocks cap off their strong year.
  • Monetary policy support. Inflation remained benign, enabling central banks around the world to maintain a very gradual pace of raising interest rates or tapering securities purchases. Most of the world’s leading central banks are only in the early stages of pulling back while the Bank of Japan is still going full speed.

In terms of what worked, growth outperformed value (largely on technology strength), large caps outperformed small and mid despite greater relevant benefits of lower tax rates for small, and international equities, notably emerging markets, outperformed U.S. equities as the U.S. dollar weakened and global growth accelerated [Figure 1].

Key Drivers For The Return Of The Business Cycle

The return of the business cycle, as discussed in our Outlook 2018, remains our major theme for the year. With the Federal Reserve (Fed) pulling back on its monetary policy support, fiscal policy and earnings will emerge as key drivers. S&P 500 companies are well positioned with the potential to generate double-digit earnings growth thanks to a combination of better economic growth and lower corporate tax rates. In addition, the ability of businesses to fully expense (100%) capital expenditures over the next five years may provide a powerful tailwind for profits. Going forward, we look for business investment and further gains in earnings per share to power the economy and equity markets, respectively.

A focus on business fundamentals and the impact of fiscal policy could have implications for equity leadership in 2018:

  • Size. Small cap stocks typically have endured a bigger tax burden than large caps, making them a big beneficiary of the new tax law generally. We also expect small caps to be a beneficiary of a stronger dollar in 2018 as the Fed gradually raises rates and shrinks its balance sheet. More domestic exposure means smaller companies do not typically experience currency translation challenges on their earnings that larger, multinational corporations confront.
  • Style. The value style of investing may benefit from the new fiscal legislation. Value tends to perform better when economic growth accelerates, which we expect to see in 2018. Higher price-to-earnings ratios (PE) for growth may attract the attention of value seekers. Higher interest rates as growth and inflation pick up, and a potentially steeper yield curve, may also support better value performance in traditional value plays such as financials.
  • Sector. We expect cyclical sectors to outperform their defensive counterparts as the economic expansion continues with help from tax reform. Our favored sectors include financials, industrials, and technology. The financials sector may benefit from a lower corporate tax rate, a steeper yield curve, and deregulation efforts. Industrials may benefit from stronger global growth, lower taxes, 100% capital expensing, higher U.S. defense spending, and a possible infrastructure spending plan. Last, solid global demand and profits held overseas that can be repatriated at attractive rates may support technology sector outperformance in 2018.

2018 Off To A Strong Start

The year is off to a strong start with the S&P 500 up 2.6% already in just four trading days, the index’s best start since 2006. Data has helped, including a strong and much better than expected December reading on the U.S. Institute for Supply Management (ISM) Manufacturing Index, at 59.7, and some of the strongest European manufacturing survey readings ever recorded. December job growth did miss expectations in Friday’s employment report (148K versus 190K Bloomberg consensus), but the miss did not slow stocks down as the S&P 500 added 0.7% on Friday.

Tax Law Clarity Drove Recent Upgrade To Forecasts

With recent clarity on the new tax law, we upgraded our forecasts for economic growth, earnings, and S&P 500 returns for 2018. In our Outlook 2018 we had forecast that the stock market’s PE multiple, at 19.5 times trailing earnings, would roughly hold steady.* Our then 8–10% S&P 500 earnings growth forecast for 2018 at that PE drove our prior 2018 year-end S&P 500 target of 2725–2750 and total return forecast of 8–10% (including dividends). (Based on expectations of better economic growth, with potential added benefit from lower corporate tax rates.)

The passage of the new tax law and its potential boost to corporate profitability led us to raise our 2018 S&P 500 earnings forecast from $142.50 to $147.50. Assuming a trailing 12-month PE of 19–20, we believe the S&P 500 would be fairly valued in the range of 2,850–2,900 by year-end 2018, or approximately 8% above closing levels on December 31, 2017. We appreciate that stock valuations are above historical averages, but we view them as fair given low interest rates and inflation.


2017 was a great year for stocks and, so far, 2018 is off to an excellent start. For more on our key themes for 2018, please refer to our Outlook 2018: Return of the Business Cycle. And for more on the economic, earnings, and market impacts of the new tax law, please refer to our Investment Implications of the New Tax Law commentary.

*The PE (price-to-earnings) ratio is a measure of the price paid for a share relative to the annual net income or profit earned by the firm per share. It is a financial ratio used for valuation: a higher PE ratio means that investors are paying more for each unit of net income, so the stock is more expensive compared to one with a lower PE ratio.

Leave a Comment