Here’s a great example of how they’ll default on Social Security

Updated on

Here’s a great example of how they’ll default on Social Security

On March 5, 1997, I signed up for the American Airlines “AAdvantage” loyalty program.

I was 18 years old and didn’t know anything about travel. Back then it was exciting to even set foot on a plane.

But over the years travel has become a huge part of my life.


I’ve been all over the world to more than 120 countries and have travelled millions of miles, including on American Airlines.

Last night, in fact, American Airlines sent me an email informing me that I had just crossed the two million mile threshold.

It took 19 years from the time I originally signed up for the program in 1997.

Now, 2 million miles on American comes with a lot of unique benefits.

For example, I now have “platinum” elite status for life.

This is common across just about every airline– they reward frequent travelers with various tiers of elite status.

So if you travel a fair bit, they reward you with “gold” status. If you travel even more, they give you “platinum” status.

And if you fly a LOT, you achieve “executive platinum” status, which is what I currently have with American (and several others).

Each tier is supposed to come with certain perks.

The highest tier travelers often receive free upgrades, bonus miles, and a dedicated reservations hotline where you can quickly get through to a real, live human being.

Lower tier travelers still get a fair amount of benefits, like being able to board the plane before anyone else and access to the priority check-in line.

Hitting the two million mile mark means that Platinum benefits have been conferred upon me for life.

Two decades ago I didn’t even think about this.

I’m sure I must have read about it in the welcome kit that American Airlines sent to me in the mail in 1997.

But the prospect of reaching two million miles and receiving some benefit for the rest of my life never factored into my calculus back then.

Over the last year or two, however, it did.

As I got closer to the milestone, I began to learn a lot more about the benefits and started arranging my travel more deliberately to include American and its partners.

But a few months ago something interesting happened.

American Airlines announced a MAJOR overhaul of its elite program. And most of the changes are bad for passengers.

For starters, they’re taking away a LOT of benefits, like making it much more difficult to receive and use the upgrades they’ve promised.

They’re also reducing the mileage bonus they provide to most members (including Platinum members).

And most notably they’ve introduced a fourth elite tier status called “Platinum Pro” that ranks ahead of “Platinum” in the pecking order for increasingly scarce benefits.

So basically this lifetime Platinum status that I just received isn’t worth very much… certainly not worth what it was a few years ago, let alone when I signed up in 1997.

It’s ironic that after 19 years in the program, they changed everything just a few months before I hit the milestone.

Candidly, the writing was on the wall. American Airlines spent two years restructuring its debts a few years ago.

The company is hardly on sound financial footing.

Social Security and airlines

And since these benefits, miles, and upgrades do represent a significant liability for the airline, it was obvious that they would take some action to reduce what they owe to their passengers.

That’s exactly what they did. Because this elite status overhaul effectively represents a default.

They made certain assertions for years about what elite status means. Now they’ve unilaterally changed it to reduce a bunch of liabilities that they can’t fulfill.

Now, I’m not here to complain about elite status changes. Frankly I couldn’t care less about the program.

Social Security and airline miles

But it is a wonderful example of how governments, pension funds, and Social Security will do the same thing– default on the promises they’ve made to taxpayers.

Think about it– when you’re young, you don’t spend much time thinking about retirement or whether your pension fund is solvent.

It’s simply not on young people’s radars, in the same way that I didn’t spend much time back in 1997 reflecting on two million miles and lifetime Platinum status.

As the milestone gets closer, however, we do start thinking about it.

We start planning. We start arranging our affairs with it in mind.

Then the inevitable happens.

Once we finally reach this milestone, they yank the carpet out from underneath us, overhauling the program and reducing the benefits they promised all those years.

Naturally, we should have seen it coming.

We should have noticed that the government was insolvent (or that the airline was bankrupt), desperate to eliminate its liabilities.

Social Security – admits its bankrupt

Social Security’s Board of Trustees delivers an annual report each year to the public stating unequivocally that they are rapidly running out of money.

One of Social Security’s major trust funds already went bust, and the other one is massively underfunded.

The Trustees cannot be more blunt in their projections: the government has no chance of keeping its promises to taxpayers

(And, by the way, the Trustees include the Treasury Secretary of the United States, among other senior government officials.)

Other pension funds are in the same boat. City and state pension funds in the US have an enormous $3.4 trillion funding gap, and most private pensions are no better.

Plus the US government’s Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation that is supposed to guarantee pension funds, is itself insolvent and in need of a bailout.

Here’s a simple truth: pension funds are no better than airlines. They will default on their promises, especially if you’re in your mid-40s or younger.

You’ll spend decades working towards retirement only to have your benefits yanked when you reach this milestone.

The good news is that you have time to plan, time to prepare, time to learn.

(We outline some options to think about here.)

Leave a Comment