Stocks Surge While Diversification Struggles

Updated on

For many investors, the post-election rise in U.S. stock prices hasn’t necessarily translated to a post-election rise in portfolio values. Does diversification still work?

Leading up to the U.S. presidential election, we saw ample evidence making a case for diversification. Exposure to high-quality, interest-rate-sensitive bonds provided a powerful diversification benefit to offset losses in equities — especially during volatility episodes like the January sell-off and the aftermath of the Brexit vote in June. Investors also benefited from a more global diversification strategy as emerging market stocks and bonds performed better than almost any other asset class. Finally, diversified investors saw returns from the near simultaneous rise across all classes, fueled in part by a continuation in accommodative central bank monetary policy.

Leading up to the election, well-diversified portfolios were rewarded

2016 asset class performance pre-U.S. election (01/01/16 – 11/08/16)


As U.S. equities move higher, other asset classes retreat

But since the U.S. election, diversified portfolios have struggled. Over this short period of time, markets have digested the implications of a more pro-economic growth, less onerous regulatory environment that could come from a Donald Trump administration and a Republican controlled House and Senate. After an initial sell-off in the early morning hours after the election, U.S. equity markets have moved higher, hitting all-time highs on what seems like a daily basis. But as I’m sure you’re aware, other asset classes have not responded with similar enthusiasm.

International equity markets have lagged noticeably as a result of a strong U.S. dollar and potential isolationist trade policies from the new administration. Interest rates rapidly rose as bond markets priced in anticipation for stronger economic growth and higher inflation. What’s more, had it not been for OPEC’s announced production cuts at the end of November, which caused oil to spike higher in price, commodities would have also delivered a relatively lackluster performance.

The result is a performance pattern where U.S. equity markets have moved higher, but almost every other asset class has moved lower. So it’s understandable that diversified investors may have been frustrated, especially when reminded that “markets” (often narrowly defined as U.S. equity markets) continue to hit all-time highs, while portfolios struggle to keep pace. In fact, the more conservative the asset allocation strategy, the worse the outcome, because fixed-income assets have suffered the most post-election.

Since the U.S. election, diversified portfolios have struggled


2016 asset class performance post-U.S. election (11/09/16 – 11/30/16)

Bottom line

While diversification has struggled in recent months, it’s important to remember not to become disenchanted with what’s been a valuable strategy throughout market history. The range of possible outcomes under a Trump administration is very wide. The timing of implementing new policies is uncertain, and a likely reduction in accommodative monetary policy could prove troublesome to any suddenly emboldened equity investors. But although rising rates caused many fixed-income assets to experience one of their worst monthly returns on record, they likely improved forward-looking return expectations; there’s a high correlation with starting yields and future returns. You’ll be serving your clients well by retaining their exposure to numerous asset classes. We expect that the benefits of diversified investing will reemerge in short order.

Source: Columbia Threadneedle Investments and Morningstar Direct as of November 30, 2016. Asset classes shown are represented by the following indices: U.S. equity (S&P 500 TR USD), Developed international equity (MSCI EAFE NR USD), Emerging market equity (MSCI EM NR USD), REITs (FTSE NAREIT All REITs TR), Commodities (Bloomberg Commodity TR USD), Global inflation-linked bonds represented by BBgBarc Global Inflation Linked TR USD), 10 Year Treasury (BofAML US Treasury Current 10 Yr TR USD), Global aggregate bonds (BBgBarc Global Aggregate TR USD), U.S. aggregate bonds (BBgBarc US Agg Bond TR USD), Investment grade corporates (BBgBarc Custom IG Corp TR USD), High yield corporates (BBgBarc High Yield Corporate TR USD), Mortgage-backed securities (BBgBarc US MBS TR USD), Emerging market bonds (JPM EMBI Global TR USD), Global 60/40 (60% MSCI ACWI NR USD and 40% BBgBarc Global Aggregate TR USD).

Article by Jeffrey L. Knight, Columbia Threadneedle Investments

Leave a Comment