BIS finds $14 trillion of dollar debt, hidden in “footnotes”

Updated on

“The message from a string of BIS [Bank of International Settlements] reports is that the US dollar
is both the barometer and agent of global risk appetite and credit leverage.
Episodes of dollar weakness – such as this year – flush the world with liquidity and
nourish asset booms. When the dollar strengthens, it becomes a headwind for stock markets and credit.”

– Ambrose Evans-Pritchard

Get The Full Ray Dalio Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Ray Dalio in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues

The US Federal Reserve and fellow central banks can be forgiven for telling us a white lie: nothing would be gained from admitting that they do not know how to extricate the world safely from their extreme monetary experiment.

Fed chair Janet Yellen has finally pulled one major trigger after countless retreats. The long-awaited reversal of quantitative easing will kick off in October.

Deutsche Bank calls it the start of the ‘Great Central Bank Unwind,’ candidate ‘Number One’ for the world’s next financial crisis.

The puzzle is why the Yellen Fed – usually so cautious – has chosen to enter these treacherous waters when there is no strict need to do so and before it has raised interest rates to minimum safe levels. This tightening sequence makes no sense.

Source:  Yellen Fed courts fate by reversing QE so soon

Ambrose Evans-Pritchard is the International Business Editor of The Telegraph. He has covered world politics and economics for 30 years.  Follow him.  He’s good.

Fed day has passed and consensus is that the Fed is hawkish (pulling the punch bowl from the party by raising rates and reducing its balance sheet of assets purchased during QE).  Yields around the globe moved higher, the 10-year Treasury note is trading back above 2.25%, the dollar rallied and remains slightly higher than prior to the Fed announcement.  Gold sold off on the news and is testing its recent upside breakout.

U.S. equities weathered the news with the broad markets mostly unchanged and financials (beneficiaries of higher rates) rallied.  International developed and emerging markets are slightly lower.

August and September are the two worst performing months for stocks each year.  You wouldn’t know it from the relative calm in the market.  From Bloomberg’s David Wilson, “This month’s pattern of calm for U.S. stocks persisted even after Federal Reserve officials laid out plans to begin selling some of the central bank’s bond holdings. The CBOE Volatility Index, or VIX, is headed for its lowest daily average in any September since calculations began in 1990.  Wednesday’s 0.4-point decline in the VIX, to 9.78, as the Fed announced the monetary-policy shift.”  The all-time low was in early 2007 at 9.39.  Readings below 10 are rare.


Here is a look at the VIX Volatility Index since 1999.  Imagine the calm confidence that set over the market in 2007.  VIX measures perceived risk.  We should get worried when everyone is comfortable and see opportunity when others are in fear.


Where is the demand for equities coming from?

One strong answer is the central banks…  With a nod toward “party on” the Bank of Japan (BOJ) voted to keep its current easy monetary policy unchanged by a vote of 8-1 (with the lone dissenter arguing for more aggressive easing).  BOJ Governor Haruhiko Kuroda said that ETF purchases are still necessary to achieve the 2% inflation target by reducing equity risk premium.  Print and buy… no concern of price or return… “Still necessary to achieve inflation…”  One has to ask/wonder what the other side of this might look like.  But when?  For now, no “other side,” at least in Japan, is in sight.  Their markets rallied on the Fed news.

I had a conversation with David Bianco of Deutsche Asset Management in early August at Camp Kotok in Maine.  He made a strong argument that we really should be keeping our eyes on the European Central Bank.  It is that liquidity that is finding its way into global equity markets, including the U.S.  Perhaps he is on to something.

Here’s what I mean…. When Draghi’s European Central Bank (ECB) creates money and buys bonds, the seller of those bonds is flush with new cash and needs to next decide what to buy.  That money finds its way to something and I contend it is bidding up stock prices.

Bank of America’s Michael Hartnett is saying the same thing.  He noted in a recent post that the Fed is not the world’s sole central bank.  We have to consider the liquidity created by the ECB, the BOJ, the Bank of England (BOE) and the People’s Bank of China (PBOC).  Hartnett notes that central banks have purchased nearly $2 trillion of financial assets year to date.

That is almost as much as the Fed purchased under QE1 during the crisis period in the early innings of the “Great Recession.”  Today, there is clearly no sign of even a mild recession, yet the love keeps on coming.

Bottom line: Those foreign central bank purchases translate to a vast sea of liquidity supporting stocks.  Hartnett calls it the “supernova of liquidity” and “the flow that conquers all.”  My motivation and title for today’s piece.

Stocks are hitting new all-time highs in both the U.S. and globally, seemingly absent any concern about the gap in fundamentals, the age of the business cycle or the geopolitical risks that seem to be sitting on a knife’s edge.

And I think it’s gonna be a long long time
‘Till touch down brings me round again to find
I’m not the man they think I am at home
Oh no no no I’m a rocket man
Rocket man burning out his fuse up here alone

– Elton John, “Rocket Man”

Yet more buyers than sellers is what it is and, at the end of the day, it is what moves prices.  Our trend models remain bullish on equities, our tactical models are long risk assets and our fixed income trend signals still bullish.

I’ve long posted a Don’t Fight the Fed and Tape (Trend) chart in Trade Signals and it’s remained bullish despite the Fed hikes since December 2015.  But we should be mindful of the liquidity coming from other central banks because that capital does find its way here.

To that end, the BOJ remains all in, game on, the Bank of England just completed its QE program in the spring.  The ECB has indicated it will begin to taper and the Fed begins its tapering journey next month.

Look, my view is that the significant risk we face is a coming “Sovereign Debt Crisis.”  The seminal issue is we sit at the end-stage of a long-term debt super cycle and a reset is likely.  Europe is a possible ground zero due to the size of debt, lack of common debt and challenged political union from north to south.  China is a possible ground zero, as are the emerging markets you’ll find listed below in the body of OMR.

And just to make it a little more interesting, S&P downgraded China’s sovereign debt citing rising “economic and financial risks.”


But wait, there’s more: According the to the Bank of International Settlements (BIS), what was believed to be $10 trillion or so in EM U.S. dollar denominated debt turns out to be nearly $25 trillion.  Seems someone was creatively hiding $14 trillion off-balance sheet.  Shades of Enron comes to mind.


We live in a complex global interconnected system.  Because of the massive size of global debt (approximately 327% of global GDP), I believe it will be a rising dollar that trips the switch.  Perhaps something else.  When?  No one can possibly know.  A lot depends on fiscal policy, global policy coordination and central bank activity.  Watch the dollar!

Let’s make sure to play both good offense and good defense.  Participate and protect and get to the next great 2009-like investment opportunity in good shape.

Grab a coffee and read on.  One more bump on my promise to deliver Barry Ritholtz’s great interview of Professor Richard Thaler.  I hope it will be available on Monday.  I’ll tweet out a link, share it on LinkedIn and include it in next week’s post.  It’s really that good.

Below, I summarize and link to an excellent piece from the great Ambrose Evans-Pritchard.  It is worth the read. You’ll love how he thinks/writes.  Finally, I also share with you a few ideas on how you might manage your downside risk.  Hope you find the information helpful and do have a great weekend.

? If you are not signed up to receive my weekly On My Radar e-newsletter, you can subscribe here. ?

Follow me on Twitter @SBlumenthalCMG.

Included in this week’s On My Radar:

  • BIS discovers $14 trillion of dollar debt offshore, hidden in “footnotes”
  • Trend Following – Two Actionable Ideas
  • Trade Signals – Inching Higher in Bull Market Trend – 09-20-2017
  • Personal Note

BIS discovers $14 trillion of dollar debt offshore, hidden in ‘footnotes’

By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard, The Telegraph (September 17, 2017)

The world’s top financial watchdog has uncovered $14 trillion of global dollar debt hidden in derivatives and swap contracts, a startling sum that doubles the underlying levels of offshore dollar credit in the international system.

The scale of this lending greatly increases the risk of a future funding crisis if inflation ever forces the US Federal Reserve to tighten hard, draining worldwide liquidity and potentially triggering a dollar surge.

A forensic study by the Bank for International Settlements says enormous liabilities have accrued through FX swaps, currency swaps, and ‘forwards’. The data is tucked away in the “footnotes” of bank reports. “Contracts worth tens of trillions of dollars stand open and trillions change hands daily. Yet one cannot find these amounts on balance sheets. This debt is, in effect, missing,” said the BIS analysis, written by team under chief economist Claudio Borio.

“These transactions are functionally equivalent to borrowing and lending in the cash market. Yet the corresponding debt is not shown on the balance sheet and thus remains obscured,” they wrote in the BIS’s quarterly report.

A breath-taking gap in global accounting rules mean that the debt is booked as a notional derivative, “even though it is in effect a secured loan with principal to be repaid in full at maturity.”

The hidden lending comes on top of $10.7 trillion of recorded offshore dollar debt outside US jurisdiction. It pushes the combined total to $25 trillion or a third of global GDP.  While these contracts serve as a lubricant and hedging device for world commerce, they can be plagued by currency and maturity mismatches.




Ok, you get the point.  Debt and leverage lead to bubbles.  And bubbles eventually pop.  Let’s keep our eye on the dollar.  A rising dollar means the foreign borrowers will owe more.  For example, if the dollar rises 10%, $25 trillion owed quickly becomes $27.5 trillion.  Of course, if the dollar declines that’s a net win for the borrower.  The problem is the size of the debt owed.  The Fed is dismounting from QE at a very tricky time.

A rising dollar is the pin to the bubble.  We keep watch…

And thus the current conundrum with the Fed raising rates and reversing course on QE.  It leads to an interest rate mismatch globally (higher yields in the U.S.) and to a stronger dollar as that higher yield spread attracts money to dollar assets.  Give me negative yield returns in Europe?  No thanks.  So yeah, there’s that.

The point is, like the sub-prime problem risk (we wrote about and got it right… yet honestly I underestimated the size of the systemic outcome), this current “Sovereign Debt” issue much larger than sub-prime.

What can you do?  In the next section I share another in a series of “what you can do” to protect your backside.

Put a few well vetted simple rules-based processes in place that you trust and can stick to.  Otherwise, find a professional who can help you.

Trend Following – Two Actionable Ideas

In the “what can you do about it” category, here are a couple ideas to think about.

Let’s look at two very simple trend following ideas.

Most of us are familiar with the 200-day moving average (MA).  It is simply a smoothing of the average price of, for example, the S&P 500 Index over the last 200 days.  Take all the daily closing prices, add them up and divide by 200.  It creates a smooth trend line that enables you to see if the trend is moving up or moving down.

In an uptrending period, the average price is moving higher.  In a downtrend, it is moving lower.  Investors can use the trend as an indicator as to when to be invested and when to hedge or get out of the market.  But one needs to have a rule to trigger a signal.  It’s one thing to see the trend line moving higher or lower, but it is another to know when to act.

One of the more popular trading indicators is called the “golden cross.”  It is when the 50-day MA price line (the shorter-term trend) crosses above or below the 200-day MA price line (the longer-term price trend).  A buy signal when it crosses above.  A sell signal when it crosses below.

Statistically, the model looks like this (next chart):

  • The middle section plots both the 50-day MA (black line) and the 200-day MA (dotted red line). A change in trend is signaled at the point in which they cross.
  • Note the two data boxes in the bottom section of the chart.
    • The left one looks at data from 1900 to September 15, 2017.
    • The right one looks at data from September 17, 2007 to September 15, 2017.
  • The gray shaded areas show the current signal. Buy signals when the 200-day MA is above the 50-day MA.
    • Note the returns in each “buy” regime of better than 9% annualized.
    • Note the annualized returns in each “sell” regime.
  • Also, I like the “% of Time” data.
    • Since 1900, the DJIA has spent 65.30% of the time in buy signals and 34.70% of the time in sell signals.
    • Since 2007, the DJIA has spent 72.91% of the time in buy signals and 27.09% of the time in sell signals.


Now, if your annualized return was 9.74% since September 17, 2007 for 72.91% of the time, your annualized portfolio return would be approximately 7.25% (if you used this process to reduce risk on sell signals.)  It would actually be higher because you would have earned money market returns when you moved to cash.  By comparison, a buy-and-hold strategy would have returned 5.21% over the same period.  Emotionally, it would also have helped you move through the period more comfortably.  You can get to a similar comparison looking at the data since 1900 in the data box (lower section of above chart – left hand side.)

Bottom line:  As you see in the above chart and in Trade Signals below, the current stock market trend remains bullish.  I like the idea of reducing risk especially if you are nearing or are in retirement.

The next model tracks the moving averages of eight different asset classes and scores them up to determine the overall trend of the stock market:

  • Upper section of the chart plots the signals: Buy (up arrows) and sell (down arrows).
  • Eight different indices are tracked and scored bullish or bearish (data box in the lower left-hand side of the chart.) The middle red section plots the combined score.
  • The data box in the lower right-hand section of the chart details the results.
    • S&P 500 Index % Gain Per Annum equaled 15.5% with 82.6% of the signals producing profitable trades.
    • The percent of time invested November 11, 1979 to September 15, 2017 was 64.4% of the time for a return of 9.98%, not including earnings on money market funds held 35.6% of the time.


I’ll see if I can get permission from Ned Davis Research to share this chart with you each week in Trade Signals.  It’s a big ask.  I’ll also ask if I can share the process rules with you.  Let me know if you’re interested in learning more… And stay tuned…

Bottom line: I like incorporating several different processes to risk manage exposure.  If you are a “DIY’er” (do-it-yourselfer) and have the discipline to stick to a process (and remove emotion from your trading), then consider using two or three different processes.  For example, follow the NDR CMG U.S. Large Cap Long/Flat Index for one-third of the equity exposure in your portfolio, use the 200-day MA cross for one-third and find another process for the final one-third.  None are perfect.  Make sure there are high win rates in the strategies.

Diversify to several different trading processes.  That’s one idea of a game plan.  Hope it gets your risk management mind going.

The goal is to get from here to there in good shape – to participate in the secular bull trends (the current state) and minimize downside losses during the secular bear trends.  Investing is about how money compounds over time.  It takes a 100% return to overcome a 50% loss and a 300% return to overcome a 75% loss.  Thus the need for downside risk management.  See “The Merciless Mathematics of Loss.”

If you are 25 to 35 years old, dollar cost average and party on.  If you are a pre-retiree like me or retiree with nearly 75% of all U.S. self-directed assets, well, we can’t afford the hit nor can we afford the 10-15 years of lost investment production it may likely take just to get back to even.

I smell a Sovereign Debt Crisis on the horizon.  It will trip the global system.  Defaults will rise, EM debt will sell off hard, banks will have issues, leverage will unwind, and liquidity will disappear.

If I’m right, the opportunity it will create will be outstanding.  You will want to be in a position to take advantage of the opportunity.  If I’m wrong, let the trend be your friend.

As a quick aside: Long-time readers know that I am a big fan of Ned Davis Research.  I’ve been a client for years and value their service.  If you’re interested in learning more about NDR, please call John P. Kornack Jr., Institutional Sales Manager, at 617-279-4876.  John’s email address is [email protected].  I am not compensated in any way by NDR.  I’m just a big fan of their work.

Trade Signals — Inching Higher in Bull Market Trend

S&P 500 Index — 2,507 (9-20-2017)

Notable this week:

The Ned Davis Research (NDR) CMG U.S. Large Cap Long/Flat Index is back to 100% fully invested in large cap exposure.  Sentiment has turned bullish, suggesting short-term caution for equities.  No other significant changes this week.  The trend remains bullish for both equity and fixed income.  High yield is in a buy signal (positive trend) as is gold.

Click here for the latest Trade Signals.

Important note: Not a recommendation for you to buy or sell any security.  For information purposes only.  Please talk with your advisor about needs, goals, time horizon and risk tolerances. 

Personal Note

The winless Shipley Gators are coming off a 0-0 tie to an impressive team.  My son, Kyle, is the goalkeeper and let’s just say he’s been getting a lot of action.  But the team is improving and they host a home game against a league rival tomorrow.  Stepson Kieran also has a game, so we’ll be racing from one to the other.  I just don’t want this time to end.

My son, Matthew, will be about an hour away on a trip to raise money for Penn State’s annual dance marathon with proceeds going to children with cancer.  They are paired with a wonderful young person and their family and get to feel the love and see the impact of their efforts.  That makes dad happy.

Brianna is also coming home for the weekend, so we’ll try to catch the PSU-Iowa football game with Matt Saturday night.  Yes, I’m one of those crazed Penn State fans and have brilliantly brainwashed my kids as well.  Admittedly over the top, Susan just gives me that look (as she should.)  But hey, it’s fun and I have a little side action with my friend, John Arthur, and his son, Chris.  They are crazed Iowa Hawkeye fans.

The highlight of the weekend will be watching my niece, Ashley, play in a softball tournament on Sunday.  My brother, Mike, passed suddenly last month and Ashley lost her wonderful father.  Mike didn’t miss a game and was affectionately nicknamed “Waterboy” by the team.




Mike Blumenthal and his daughter Ashley

The upcoming travel schedule is not too bad.  I’m in DC on October 11-12 for a conference and Dallas on October 25-26 for a famous Mauldin Solutions chili dinner.  He really does make the best chili I’ve ever had and his prime rib is equally outstanding.  John and the four strategists that make up his Mauldin Solutions Smart Core portfolio will be presenting to a select group of independent investment advisors.  I’ll be in beautiful Charleston for a meeting with Forbes publishing on October 30.  That should be interesting.

Wishing you a wonderful weekend.  Hug your family… and love and enjoy the ride as much as you can.  Life is way too short.  Really looking forward to watching Ashley play on Sunday.

? If you are not signed up to receive my weekly On My Radar e-newsletter, you can subscribe here. ?

With kind regards,


Stephen B. Blumenthal
Executive Chairman & CIO
CMG Capital Management Group, Inc.

Leave a Comment