When considering a new investment I generally expect to hold it for a minimum of 2 or 3 years; if you have a dissonant view about a certain security (and that is the secret to making a decent return in the stock market) you can’t expect Mr. Market to suddenly change his mind just because YOU purchase the security. It takes time. After all, how long does it take YOU to change your mind about an investment? and remember, Mr. Market is quite a stubborn fellow. Prone to excess, but quite a stubborn fellow. A company generally needs to demonstrate that it is on a track to exceed Mr. Market’s expectations for a number of quarters if not years before Mr. Market can swallow his pride and re-price its equity. I think we can acknowledge that changing ones mind about an investment is perhaps one of the MOST difficult thing for an individual to do, and Mr. Market, after all, is just an amalgam of individuals.
So how is it that I have exited my last investment, NACCO Industries (NC), after less than 2 months? Well, incredible as it may seem, Mr. Market has changed his mind about NC and revalued it (and it’s spin-off progeny, Hamilton Beach (HBB)) by close to 70% in less than 2 months! Is it possible that by spinning off the Hamilton Beach, NC management has increased the intrinsic value of the now-separate companies by 70%? I hardly think so. Perhaps NC was trading at only 60% of its intrinsic value in the first place and the spinoff lifted the shroud from Mr. Market’s eyes? Well, maybe. I’m just not sure that pre-spin NC was trading at 50% or 40% of its ‘intrinsic value’ and so I have exited my position with a quite reasonable 68% gain.
My primary reason for selling is that my initial thesis has proved out; the spinoff repriced the equity to take into account the two different businesses. And secondly, the shares have already risen beyond my target exit price and I no longer see the same upside as I did at the time of my initial investment. The future for the two companies does look a bit fuzzy right now; we haven’t seen stand-alone company performance yet for either one. Furthermore, on a short-term horizon, 3rd quarter earnings will be released for both companies this week. Will they disappoint? I don’t know. Perhaps not and both securities will rocket to another 70% increase. But then again, there could be a disappointing earnings announcement with a resultant fall in one or both share prices. With this uncertainty and the market in such a heady state overall I think it is prudent to take a bit of money off the table.
Carlson Capital's Double Black Diamond Fund posted a return of 3.3% net of fees in August, according to a copy of the fund's letter, which ValueWalk has been able to review. Q3 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more Following this performance, for the year to the end of August, the fund has produced a Read More
As you will remember NC had (and still has) a two class share structure; class A shares are publicly traded on the NYSE while class B shares are held by the controlling family and have 10x the voting rights of class A shares. When Hamilton Beach (HBB) was spun out of NC on Sept 30 each NACCO shareholder, whether class A or B, received one class A share and one class B share of Hamilton Beach for each NC share owned as of the record date. I would have thought that shareholders of NC class A shares would receive only class A shares in HBB and class B shareholders class B shares, but this was not the case. All NC shareholders, whether class A or B shareholders, received the same securities in the spin-off. The issue here is that HBB class B shares are not registered on any exchange and therefore not salable. In order to sell your HBB class B shares you must first exchange them for class A shares. As I have now discovered from my broker the class B shares are not in book form so there must be a physical exchange!! In short, this appears to mean it will take up to 6 weeks for HBB class A shares to appear in my account after my exchange request. Oh, and, of course, there is a $30 fee to do this! So to dispose of all my shares, besides selling the NC and HBB shares in my account, I have also had to short a number of HBB shares equal to the class A shares that I will receive after the exchange is completed and the class A shares delivered. Hopefully the mechanics will work out without too much difficulty (or cost).
As to a new position, yes, I have begun accumulating shares in a preferred issue that I will post about when I have a full position… it’s a rather illiquid security and I don’t want competition from my two readers out there!
As always, the above is my view on the aforementioned securities; please do your own due diligence as I am more likely to be wrong than right!
Article by Long Term Value Blog