International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) Blames PA, PA Blames IBM

International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) Blames PA, PA Blames IBM

International Business Machines Corp. (NYSE:IBM) was contracted by Pennsylvania to provide software to handle Pennsylvania’s  unemployment compensation system, but that contract is dead in the water following cost overruns of $60 million based on an original budget of $106.9 million. Never mind that it was also 42 months behind schedule. While the contract is done, the lawsuits should continue for years with both sides blaming the other.

International Business Machines Corp. (IBM) Blames PA, PA Blames IBM

International Business Machines Corp. (NYSE:IBM) vs PA

The state’s Secretary of Labor and Industry, Julia Hearthway, made the decision following an $800,000 an independent study conducted by Carnegie Mellon University’s Software Engineering Institute, that blames both IBM and the state.

Seth Klarman’s 2021 Letter: Baupost’s “Never-Ending” Hunt For Information

Baupost's investment process involves "never-ending" gleaning of facts to help support investment ideas Seth Klarman writes in his end-of-year letter to investors. In the letter, a copy of which ValueWalk has been able to review, the value investor describes the Baupost Group's process to identify ideas and answer the most critical questions about its potential Read More

InfoWorld reports that Hearthway halted the project because, “the problems we’ve identified cannot be solved.” IBM said it was “surprised by today’s announcement,” adding, “In complex information technology implementations, there is accountability on both sides for system performance and service delivery.”

Hearthway, not wishing to back down, or take any blame given the inevitable lawsuit shot back with, “We’ve been meeting weekly with them and they know full well all the problems. That’s ridiculous that they say they’re surprised. They must be in denial.”

While that’s to be expected, let’s look to the Carnegie Mellon study to sort out some of this IT train wreck.

Report on International Business Machines Corp. (NYSE:IBM)

The report’s findings blame both sides while focusing  on three primary reasons: software quality; procurement and implementation; and program management.

The report defends and blames IBM saying its development plan was up to, “industry and company standards and practices,” although the company lacked the “discipline to execute.” It also blames PA for its failure to oversee IBM properly and also suggested that there was a measure of inexperience on display by PA, while IBM may have rested on its name some.

As to procurement and implementation, the report once again blames both sides. The incomplete and ambiguous procurement specifications created by Pennsylvania was flawed from the beginning and created a poor foundation for the entire project. That said, IBM in its experience should never have accepted flawed specifications. Certainly there is more to it, but the report is quite lengthy and that is the gist of the myriad problems that occurred. For a comprehensive summary and report details have a read here.

Lastly, ineffective governance and program management cemented failure as the project encountered difficulties. Throughout the project, neither Pennsylvania nor International Business Machines Corp. (NYSE:IBM) established clear metrics and expected outcomes against which they could measure progress. Additionally, Pennsylvania personnel earmarked to this project was seriously lacking.

The whole affair should serve as a road map for private and public entities in how not to go about large IT projects.


Updated on

While studying economics, Brendan found himself comfortably falling down the rabbit hole of restaurant work, ultimately opening a consulting business and working as a private wine buyer. On a whim, he moved to China, and in his first week following a triumphant pub quiz victory, he found himself bleeding on the floor based on his arrogance. The same man who put him there offered him a job lecturing for the University of Wales in various sister universities throughout the Middle Kingdom. While primarily lecturing in descriptive and comparative statistics, Brendan simultaneously earned an Msc in Banking and International Finance from the University of Wales-Bangor. He's presently doing something he hates, respecting French people. Well, two, his wife and her mother in the lovely town of Antigua, Guatemala. <i>To contact Brendan or give him an exclusive, please contact him at [email protected]</i>
Previous article Groupon Inc (GRPN) Continues Its Rise With New CEO
Next article Market News: BlackBerry, Cliffs Natural, GAP, J.C. Penney, Ubiquiti

No posts to display