Value Investing

Heartland Advisors Says Index Investors Are Open To Painful Losses When The Inevitable Correction Occurs

One of the value investing firms we like to watch closely here at The Acquirer’s Multiple is Heartland Advisors run by Founder and CIO Bill Nasgovitz. In its most recent market commentary Heartland says, current market levels point to rampant group think where a single popular view spreads and no one stops to ask the hard questions. Here’s an excerpt from that commentary:

The lazy days of summer are just beginning, but for the markets, they’ve been going on for several years. Signs of indifference are widespread. For example, instead of rolling up their sleeves and doing the hard work of fundamental analysis, many investors have taken the path of least resistance and simply poured money into passive index funds and exchange traded funds (ETF). While these products may serve a role in an asset allocation strategy, we’d suggest current valuations leave them open to painful losses if, and when, an inevitable correction occurs.

Current low volatility for stocks, in our view, is another symptom of the lackadaisical route many are following. As shown below, the Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index (VIX) has been shuffling along near historic lows for months. Levels like this often point to rampant group think where a single popular view spreads and no one stops to ask the hard questions—what happens when interest rates go up? Can big tech really grow fast enough to support current lofty valuations?

Get The Timeless Reading eBook in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Timeless Reading in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

Too Quiet?

Index Investors Correction

Source: Bloomberg L.P. and Heartland Advisors, Inc., 6/1/2012 to 6/30/2017

Chicago Board Options Exchange Market Volatility Index (VIX Index)

Past performance does not guarantee future results.

In the first half of 2017, the VIX dipped below 10 on seven occasions—as many occurrences as the previous 22 years combined!

Many management teams, recognizing an effortless way to boost earnings, have taken to borrowing on the cheap to fund stock buybacks. With fewer shares outstanding, earnings can go up without any actual improvement in margins and sales.  Thanks to an all-too-willing Federal Reserve Board that has flooded the economy with easy money, the low effort approach has been working—at least for now.

So what could bring an end to this current cycle? Here are a few things we are watching:

  • Anemic gross domestic product growth points to earnings pressure going forward.
  • Consumer debt levels that are at pre-financial crisis highs.
  • A softer dollar that could trigger higher inflation and raise costs for businesses.
  • The impact of elevated short-term interest rates, which could take a toll on highly leveraged companies.

These items could be a headwind for many companies but expensive growth names may be the ones with the most to lose. Based on current multiples, the market is pricing in growth for these businesses that outpaces even some of the most optimistic scenarios from analysts. That means the slightest earnings misstep could be magnified and result in significant pressure.

The future, in our view, is much brighter for reasonably valued companies. As growth/momentum begins to wilt under the weight of ever increasing expectations, value should once again attract investor attention. Additionally, many sensibly priced businesses are just beginning to see their earnings inflect and, therefore, will be building off a more manageable comparison base as opposed to trying to meet unrealistic projections. Put simply, we’d rather invest in businesses that have ample room to improve than those that have no room for error.

Here are a few more reasons for optimism:

  • Housing is robust.
  • Consumer confidence remains strong and small businesses are upbeat.
  • Merger and acquisition activity appears to be heating up among smaller companies.

The mixture of good and bad, points to the need for doing the hard work of evaluating opportunities. We agree with Coach Lombardi’s words and would add that in investing, not only does work come before success but a lack of it often leads to losses.

We thank you for your continued trust and confidence.

You can read the full commentary here.

Article by Johnny Hopkins, The Acquirer's Multiple