Big management shake-up at the Sequoia fund which has been a long time bull on Valeant Pharmaceuticals. Bob Goldfard who is the CEO will be departing the firm, according to a letter which the firm sent to investors. Although, Valeant is only mentioned once, it is likely the main reason behind the management change, which recently led to two board members leaving the famed mutual fund. The fund had big losses on the VRX stake in 2015, and it is a big drag on performance this year, as well. The news was first reported by the WSJ.
Readers can find the letter from Sequoia fund below.
Gates Capital: Why (Free) Cash (Flow) Is King
Gates Capital Management's ECF value fund has earned strong returns for investors since its inception in June 1996. The ECF, or Excess Cash Flow Fund, had returned 12.9% annualized since inception to the end of September 2020. That was compared to 8.9% for the S&P 500 total return index and 7.4% for the HFRI Event-Driven Read More
After an extraordinary 45-year career in investing, Bob Goldfarb, our Chief Executive Officer and Sequoia Fund co-manager, is retiring. David Poppe, who has served as the co-manager of Sequoia for the past 10 years alongside Bob, will replace him as Ruane, Cunniff & Goldfarb’s CEO and will now serve as the lead manager of Sequoia, as part of an investment process that will showcase the talents of one of the best research teams in our industry. The board of Sequoia Fund fully supports these changes.
A uniquely brilliant student of business, Bob played an important and valued role in producing the outstanding long-term investing record of which we now become the stewards. Over 45 years through the end of 2015, Sequoia Fund has returned 14.0% per annum versus 10.8% for the S&P 500 index, with $10,000 invested at Sequoia’s inception worth $3.9 million, versus $1.0 million for the same amount invested in the index. Over the last twenty years, we have returned 10.2% per annum, versus 8.2% per annum for the index. Perhaps most meaningfully, over the 36 rolling ten-year periods since inception, Sequoia has only underperformed the index twice— for the decade ended 1994 and the decade ended 1999.
We owe these achievements to immense talents like Bill Ruane, Rick Cunniff and Bob Goldfarb, but we believe that we owe our success first and foremost to a simple but powerful strategy: The careful selection of a focused portfolio comprised of intensively researched investments, purchased with a margin of safety. While we have beaten the market over the past decade, through the end of 2015, our investment in Valeant has diminished a record that we have built over two generations and in which we take great pride. We are a loyal, dedicated and intensely driven group, and to the extent that we have lost any of our investors’ confidence, we are determined to win it back. While our commitment to a value-oriented strategy grounded in extensive primary research remains as strong as ever, the Valeant experience has spurred a period of reflection. Going forward, we have resolved to take a more collaborative approach to constructing the portfolio that will feature a more significant role for our senior analysts, including Greg Alexander, Jonathan Brandt, Arman Gokgol-Kline, John Harris, Trevor Magyar, Terence Paré, David Poppe, Chase Sheridan and Greg Steinmetz. Our team boasts a combined tenure at Ruane Cunniff of more than 125 years, and several members have successfully managed significant sums of client capital for more than a combined 50 years.
As we have noted many times over our history, it is inevitable that from time to time, our concentrated approach to portfolio construction will cause us to diverge from the market averages. In 1999, Sequoia underperformed the S&P index by 37 percentage points. Over 1972 and 1973, we underperformed by 23 percentage points. Though past performance is obviously no guarantee of future results, and though different factors admittedly drove each of these rough patches, we have every expectation that we will recover from this one by staying focused on our core principles of outstanding investment research, thoughtful security selection and stringent price discipline. We are grateful for your patience during a disappointing period. We are profoundly fortunate to have attracted over the years a client and shareholder base possessed of a uniquely long-term perspective that aligns with our own. We realize we have a special relationship with our investors that is unusual in the investment industry. We have earned it by delivering strong investment results over a long period, and we are confident that we will continue to prove ourselves worthy of it in the future. We think often about our founders Bill Ruane and Rick Cunniff—their values, their achievements and their legacy. The challenge of living up to the example they set for us is a constant one that we embrace, and as we take it up under the next generation of our firm’s leadership, we find ourselves energized.
Sequoia Fund Full letter in PDF below