Sentiment Survey: Bonds vs Stocks

Updated on
This article reviews the data from the latest weekly sentiment survey we conduct over on Twitter.  The survey measures respondents’ equity and bond positioning/view – differentiating between whether the view is bullish or bearish for technical or fundamental reasoning.  The latest results show an extension of the rebound in technical driven bullish sentiment, while fundamental net-bulls continue to range.

Get The REITs eBook in PDF

Get The Full REITs eBook In PDF

Probably the most interesting part of the survey is the interrelation between the bond and equity surveys.  I also run the same survey for bonds, and as I show below the movement in bond and equity sentiment is largely as you would expect.  That is, when bullishness rises on equities, it usually falls for bonds (makes sense, because stocks and bonds are typically either low or negatively correlated assets).
In terms of the actual trends, bond fundamentals sentiment has become the most net-bearish overall since October last year. When you think about the proximity of the FOMC meeting this week and the likelihood that the Fed introduces QT, it makes for what might be a very interesting week for the bond market!
Fundamentals sentiment continues to run in a tight range for equities, whereas technical sentiment has rebounded after deeply bearish readings recently - which in hindsight turned out to be a false alarm.  At present there's not much in the way of extreme readings on either chart, so no immediate signal as such.

542496 4816ac2f2a6f4401a9ee70a4fd0c024b~mv2

Tracking the course of overall net-bulls for equity and bonds sentiment, you can see the moves have been fairly consistent for bonds vs equities (bonds tend to move inversely to equities, so it makes sense - note the bond sentiment line in that chart is inverted).

542496 129632dc1cc242e2a7f76f619094c71f~mv2

Looking in particular at the "fundamentals" net-bullish sentiment for bonds and equities (note the chart shows a rolling 4 week average) you can see the broader trend is being shaped by the perception of fundamentals.  Interestingly the perception of fundamentals has been very consistent across bonds and equities (again, this makes sense because a stronger economy is typically good for stocks, but bad for bonds).  In the latest reading bond fundamentals sentiment is moving lower, which may herald a move higher for equity fundamentals sentiment...  the better global economic backdrop would support this.

542496 a779e203984747e1b29e2e8d9c7e8a17~mv2

For institutional grade insights on the global economics and asset allocation, and some more good charts you may want to subscribe to the Weekly Macro Themes.  Click through for a trial.

Signup to ValueWalk!

Get the latest posts on what's happening in the hedge fund and investing world sent straight to your inbox! 
This is information you won't get anywhere else!