Home Business Index Investing: It’s Not What You Think

Index Investing: It’s Not What You Think

When you purchase through our sponsored links, we may earn a commission. By using this website you agree to our T&Cs.

The passive strategy that all investors can follow simultaneously is hold the capitalization weighted market index.  Most indexes are designed with this fact in mind.  For instance, Vanguard offers two widely held exchange traded index funds, VOO and VTI.  The first tracks the S&P 500 and the second, which is even broader, tracks virtually and exchange traded stocks.  Both are capitalization weighted.

Get The Full Warren Buffett Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Warren Buffett in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues

Q4 2019 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

Based on the foregoing, most investors conclude that holding a market capitalization weighted index is a passive that simply gives general exposure to the market.  But there is an important sense in which the issue is more complicated.  As an initial illustration, Exhibit 1 plots the time path of $1 invested in a capitalization weighted index of all U.S. stocks along with an equal weighted index of the same stocks over the period from 1926 to 2018.  (The data are from the Center for Research in Securities prices, or CRSP.)

Capitalization weighted index explained

Whereas $1 invested in the capitalization weighted index rises to $5,149, $1 invested in the equal weighted index jumps to $38,048.  There are various explanations for the difference.  One is that there is a “size” effect in that smaller capitalization stocks offer greater expected returns.  Small capitalization stocks are a tiny fraction of the capitalization weighted index, but a significant fraction of the equal weighted index.  Another possible explanation is mean reversion in stock prices.

When a company’s stock price runs up significantly it generally becomes large capitalization and gets a greater weight in cap weighted ones.  Suppose that the run-up is based on two components: one, an improvement in the company’s fundamentals, and, two, irrational exuberance regarding the company’s outlook.  If both factors are in play, whose prices have run-up sharply will tend to be overpriced.  For this reason, capitalization weighted indexes will also tend to be overpriced as well.

Based on this argument, Rob Arnott and Jason Hsu developed what they called fundamental indexes that are weighted by factors such as sales, employment, book value and total assets rather than market capitalization.  (Literature on the fundamental indexes is available from Research Affiliates, a firm founded by Mr. Arnott)  They found that such fundamental indexes tended to outperform standard capitalization weighted indexes over long periods of time.

capitalization weighted index

Capitalization weighted index and FAANG

It is also striking the extent to which capitalization weighted indexes can come to be dominated by a relatively few companies in one sector of the economy.  For instance, the five largest companies by market capitalization in the United States are, in order, Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Facebook.  All five are giant tech companies that seen their stock valuations rise dramatically.  Over the last five years: Apple is up 160%, Microsoft is up 236%%, Alphabet is 160%, Amazon is up 481%, and Facebook is up 160%.  And those increase are starting from already large market capitalization.  As result, those five companies alone account for over 16% of the S&P 500 as shown in the exhibit below.  Only during the tech bubble of 2000 was the S&P 500 so dominated by only five companies.

As a result of the foregoing, it turns out that a “passive” investment in the S&P 500 is, to an extent, an “active” investment in five big tech companies and an even more active investment in the technology sector.  In comparison, those five companies would constitute only 1% of an equally weighted portfolio.

Index Investing

Tech and index investing

The predominance of the tech sector in the market portfolio is not limited to the big five.  Right behind the big five are foreign tech giants Alibaba and Tencent that trade on U.S. exchanges.  In addition, “techier” companies tend to trade at richer valuations than their more traditional counterparts in the same industry.  Compare, for example, the pricing of Tesla with that of Ford or GM.  This further tilts capitalization weighted indexes in the direction of tech exacerbating the extent to which investment in a capitalization weighted market index is an investment in tech.

The foregoing should not be interpreted to imply that investing in a capitalization weighted index is a poor choice for any particular investor.  However, it is designed to point out that in today’s market buying a capitalization index is not “passive” in the sense that many investors might think it is.  To a meaningful extent, it is an investment in huge tech companies and the tech sector.  That is something that investors should keep in mind.

Our Editorial Standards

At ValueWalk, we’re committed to providing accurate, research-backed information. Our editors go above and beyond to ensure our content is trustworthy and transparent.

Prof. Bradford Cornell, Cornell Capital Group

Want Financial Guidance Sent Straight to You?

  • Pop your email in the box, and you'll receive bi-weekly emails from ValueWalk.
  • We never send spam — only the latest financial news and guides to help you take charge of your financial future.