Home Politics Apple Refuses to Prohibit McCarthyist Blacklisting of conservative workers

Apple Refuses to Prohibit McCarthyist Blacklisting of conservative workers

When you purchase through our sponsored links, we may earn a commission. By using this website you agree to our T&Cs.

Free Enterprise Project Seeks to Protect Conservative Employees from Workplace Discrimination in Silicon Valley

Apple Fights to Maintain Anti-Conservative Status Quo

Know more about Russia than your friends:

Get our free ebook on how the Soviet Union became Putin's Russia.

Q3 2019 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

Washington, D.C. – Apple's legal team argued in a recent federal filing that the tech giant should not be obliged even to ask shareholders whether it should protect its employees, and potential hires, against blacklisting and other adverse employment actions on the basis of their political views or moral philosophy.

Apple's filing is in response to a Free Enterprise Project (FEP) shareholder proposal that asks the tech giant to produce a report detailing the potential risks to the company that arise from allowing discrimination on the basis of political affiliation or viewpoint. Apple has not only failed to prohibit the practice on its own, but has also refused to authorize the report on potential risks arising from such discrimination, or even to put the question of whether to authorize such a report to its shareholders. Instead, Apple petitioned the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to allow removal of FEP's proposal from its proxy statement and to deny the company's investors the right even to consider the resolution.

"Rather than embrace a prime opportunity to rectify this glaring omission in its non-discrimination policy, Apple is wasting its shareholders' resources to fight even having to ask its investors whether it should prepare a report to see if McCarthyist viewpoint discrimination is a bad idea," said Scott Shepard, FEP coordinator at the National Center for Public Policy Research. "Apple is either unaware or unwilling to admit that it is fighting tooth and nail to keep open its option to revisit the dark old days of blacklisting and the sort of viewpoint discrimination that hobbles civil society. We had hoped for better from a corporation that ran a Super Bowl ad more than 30 years ago warning of exactly these perils."

Apple and Silicon Valley politics

The current state of Silicon Valley harkens back to "the McCarthy Era," when government and private industry "blacklisted" those with minority political viewpoints, costing them their jobs and their livelihoods. Major political, media, and literary figures rallied against McCarthyism, with the result that the American people reached a broad consensus that discrimination in employment on the grounds of political viewpoint was beyond the pale. Recently, though, that consensus has weakened, especially in Apple's own Silicon Valley, where instances of viewpoint discrimination in employment have begun to appear again, along with an increasing sense of the pervasiveness and dangers of such discrimination.

In prior eras, discrimination was largely aimed against Communists or those on the far left of the American political spectrum. These days the bias is aimed toward the right. But this time the blacklist doesn't threaten only those with fringe beliefs. Mainstream right-of-center conservatives are being "deplatformed," harassed, driven to silence – and even driven out of their jobs and educational opportunities – throughout the educational and technology worlds.

FEP's proposal asks Apple to allow shareholders to vote on whether to prepare a report on the potential risks that arise from failing to prohibit viewpoint discrimination. It notes:

Companies with inclusive policies are better able to recruit the most talented employees from a broad labor pool, resolve complaints internally to avoid costly litigation or reputational damage, and minimize employee turnover. Moreover, inclusive policies contribute to more efficient human capital management by eliminating the need to maintain different policies in different locations.

Apple will not stop the blacklisting?

In response, Apple petitioned the SEC asking that it be allowed to remove FEP's proposal. Apple claimed that its current anti-discrimination policy, which provides no protections for those with differing political views, is good enough, and that shareholders had already demonstrated their comfort with a company culture that does not protect employees' freedom of opinion.

"Apple's effort to block our shareholder resolution is part of a continued pattern of the tech giant's anti-conservative bias," said FEP Director Justin Danhof, Esq., the author of the shareholder proposal. "Last year, we asked Apple's board to consider expanding the viewpoint diversity of its monolithically liberal set of directors, but the company steadfastly refused. At that same shareholder meeting, an audience member told company CEO Tim Cook about her close friend who works at Apple and who lives in fear of retribution every single day because she happens to be a conservative. What she described was the textbook definition of a hostile work environment. So we filed a resolution seeking to protect such employees. Now Apple's leadership is essentially saying it wants to retain the right to punish employees for conservative thought."

"This discrimination has no place in American workplaces, colleges, communications platforms, or American life generally. It's just as wrong now as it was in the 1950s, no matter who it victimizes," said Shepard. "Most of us learned about the horrors of McCarthyism as we grew up, but now Apple's leaders seem to have forgotten the lesson. The SEC should reject Apple's embarrassing and tin-eared opposition to our proposal. We hope and trust that the shareholders will be able to remind Apple that the company was once a place that fostered and protected free thought and expression."

Sign up for email updates here.

Our Editorial Standards

At ValueWalk, we’re committed to providing accurate, research-backed information. Our editors go above and beyond to ensure our content is trustworthy and transparent.

Jacob Wolinsky

Want Financial Guidance Sent Straight to You?

  • Pop your email in the box, and you'll receive bi-weekly emails from ValueWalk.
  • We never send spam — only the latest financial news and guides to help you take charge of your financial future.