How To Tell If Your Value Proposition Misses The Mark
August 30, 2016
by Dan Solin
Advisor Perspectives welcomes guest contributions. The views presented here do not necessarily represent those of Advisor Perspectives.
Advisors are focused on defining their value proposition. It’s a worthy and necessary goal. The rise of less expensive robo-advisors, a shift towards index-based investing and the reduced opportunity to add alpha are all contributing to the urgent need to answer this question: How do you justify your fee?
The responses to this inquiry that I’ve seen generally fall into two categories:
- Slogans designed to inspire confidence
- Efforts to quantify the value you add
I find both approaches lacking. Here’s why.
Slogans are unconvincing
In an effort to persuade clients that they add value, some advisory firms create slogans designed to convey the impression of a special relationship with their clients. These can range from simply stating “we care” to “dedicated to your success” and everything in-between. You can find an exhaustive list of financial slogans here. When you read them, put yourself in the shoes of a prospect. Did any of these slogans make you want to do business with the entity using them?
Slogans are often expressed on web pages, much the way a subtitle is set forth under the title to a book. Advisors try to associate the slogan with the firm.
Most of the slogans are unconvincing and self-serving. I agree with the views of Eric Swartz, a “sloganeer and branding strategist,” who stated, “If a slogan appears self-centered and self-serving, it probably is.”
Slogans that fit squarely within the “self-centered and self-serving” category are those that attribute abstract qualities to your firm, like lofty ethics, honesty, trustworthiness and caring. The basic problem with these slogans is that anyone can adopt them. They are often used by unscrupulous people as part of a fraudulent scheme. In one case, the SEC charged a trio of business associates in California with stealing investors’ money while promising them “indestructible wealth.” They also used this slogan: “Finances God’s Way.”
The fact that slogans can be so easily misused has lessened their persuasive power and made investors leery of them. While the right slogan still has a place in your marketing strategy, don’t rely on it to establish your value proposition.
Efforts to quantify your value fall short
Perhaps the best publicized, most credible effort to quantify the value of advisors was a white paper authored by Vanguard. The paper concluded that advisors can add “about 3%” in net returns. It calculated this by quantifying the value of reduction in expense ratios, rebalancing, behavioral coaching, asset location and spending strategy (withdrawal order). It also noted the benefits of a suitable asset allocation and “total-return versus income investing,” although it did not quantify those benefits.
Others have made notable efforts to quantify advisor value, complete with an impressive “hierarchy of advisor value.”
While I applaud this work, it’s more convincing to other advisors than it is to prospects. Here’s why:
First, prospects get many of these benefits from robo-advisors at a lower cost. Not all of these benefits may be available currently from fully automated advisors (although they likely will be in the future), but “hybrid” robo-advisors, like those offered by Vanguard that include access to a qualified advisor, can easily provide them. Michael Kitces, director of research for Pinnacle Advisory Group, correctly noted that the Vanguard robo offering represents “a continuing threat to independent advisors.”
Second, the data doesn’t make an emotional connection with prospects. It’s too abstract and impersonal. It’s presented in a way that appeals to sophisticated advisors, but not to unsophisticated (and perhaps some sophisticated) prospects. It’s also complex and involves an extensive (and excruciatingly boring) presentation that is not likely to resonate with prospects.