Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)’s Retail France Company has been under watch by France’s data regulator for the last year, and apparently the watch continues. According to The Global Legal Post, Apple received the first public notice about the video surveillance system that’s installed in its Opera Apple Store in Paris in December 2013.
Apple asked to redirect cameras
In that first notice, regulators requested that Apple redirect some of its cameras. Specifically, the French Data Protection Authority (the CNIL) targeted the cameras located in employee-only areas. The agency also asked Apple to inform employees that the video surveillance system is in use.
Recently, Bruce Greenwald carried out a virtual Fireside Chat with Li Lu, the founder and chairman of Himalaya Capital. Greenwald and Lu covered multiple topics during the discussion, addressing everything from the value investor's approach to appraising businesses and what he had learned from his great friend Charlie Munger. The duo also discussed China's economy Read More
Apple’s Opera store did fix the problems, but regulators noted the same issues in other Apple retail stores in France. As a result, the CNIL sent another public notice to the company about 16 of its retail locations in the country.
French regulators said any company that installs surveillance cameras must tell employees that the system is in use and explain procedures relating to the right of access to the videos. Additionally, the company must respect workers’ right to privacy, not film employees at their work stations or in break areas or restrooms. Companies may only collect video necessary “for the pursuit of the predefined purposes of such a processing,” according to the report.
The CNIL said all of the 16 French Apple stores it investigated found existing cameras in sensitive areas like near access doors or locked safes. Regulators also found cameras around employees’ work stations, circulation spaces, break areas and the coatroom.
Investigators also found that Apple did inform employees that a video surveillance system is in use in its internal bylaws, which they receive upon their hiring. However, the information in some stores was supplemented by a display that’s “hardly visible” and located in public areas. Also officials said Apple did not provide complete information according to legal requirements in France.
Apple not sanctioned yet
French regulators have ordered Apple to make sure each camera’s implementation “is not disproportionate to its purpose” and doesn’t permanently video tape employees. In order to comply, Apple must adopt masking measures or reposition cameras unless there is some kind of extraordinary circumstances related to the nature of the workers’ tasks.
They also ordered the company to inform workers that there’s a video surveillance system in use in a display posted in a public employee-only area. The posting must also explain employees’ rights in terms of being able to access the videos.
Apple does not face any penalties at this time. However, regulators could sanction the company if it fails to comply with the orders.
Not the first time Apple France got in trouble
Last year Apple also faced some antitrust allegations in France. Officials raided the company’s French headquarters. They accused Apple of abusing its dominance, unfair competition and abusing economic dependence.