Home Personal Finance Is Your IRA Provider Holding You Back?

Is Your IRA Provider Holding You Back?

When you purchase through our sponsored links, we may earn a commission. By using this website you agree to our T&Cs.

5 ways to tell it’s time to switch brokers.

While brokerage firms may not top the list of providers you’re actively considering switching, not regularly benchmarking your current broker could be costly to your retirement.

Fees, commissions and outdated tools can quietly chip away at your returns, while a lack of investment options or poor customer service could limit your ability to capitalize on new opportunities.

By periodically comparing your broker’s offerings against competitors, you can ensure you’re getting the best value and support to meet your financial goals. Staying with an underperforming broker might mean missing out on better features and more profitable strategies.

Here are some signs that it might be time to search for a new broker.

1. Your broker charges high fees or commissions

One clear sign that it may be time to switch brokers is if you pay excessive account fees or trade commissions. While many brokers have ditched commissions on stocks and exchange-traded funds (ETFs), options, mutual funds and other financial products can still carry noticeable costs. Commissions can significantly lower your profits over time, depending on your trading activity.

Additionally, if your broker charges extra for research tools, data access or inactivity, those costs can quickly add up.

By comparing your broker’s fee structure with competitors, you can find that you’re paying more than necessary. Reducing these costs by switching to a broker with lower fees or a more transparent fee structure can improve your overall returns and help you reach your financial goals faster.

The Finder & Tastytrade Retail Investor Sentiment Report reveals that trading fees (39.1%) are the number one factor prompting investors to switch trading platforms, followed by customer service (30.4%) and ease of use (29.2%).

2. You’ve outgrown your broker’s limited investment options and trading tools

Beginner-focused brokers that center on stock and ETF investing are great if you’re just learning the ropes, but these platforms may become limiting as you progress as an investor and seek to incorporate more advanced trading techniques into your strategy.

With access to diverse investment vehicles, trading tools and research, you can tailor your strategy to different market conditions and financial goals and, importantly, make informed investment decisions.

If you’re finding it difficult to explore new asset classes or take advantage of emerging market opportunities due to your broker’s limited offerings and lack of research tools, it might be time to consider a switch to an IRA provider that can support your evolving investing style.

3. Your broker’s customer service stinks

Consistently poor customer service is another key indicator that it might be time to switch brokers. Whether you’re dealing with long wait times, unresponsive support or representatives who lack the knowledge to assist you, bad service can add unnecessary stress and delay critical decisions.

In the fast-paced investing world, access to timely and effective customer support is essential — especially if you’re dealing with issues related to account management, trade execution or platform glitches.

If your broker’s customer service consistently leaves you frustrated or uncertain, it may cost you both time and money. Switching to a broker with a reputation for excellent, responsive support can make your overall trading experience smoother, more reliable and more enjoyable, allowing you to focus on growing your investments rather than troubleshooting problems.

4. Its mobile or online experience is inadequate and antiquated

Today’s digital world requires an intuitive and efficient mobile or online trading platform experience. If your broker’s platform is slow, difficult to navigate or prone to glitches, it can lead to missed opportunities and frustration.

Whether you’re an active trader or a long-term investor, you need a reliable, user-friendly platform that lets you easily access your account, execute trades and monitor your portfolio on the go.

If you’re constantly battling a clunky interface, frequent outages or a mobile app that lacks essential features, it may be time to switch brokers. A well-designed and seamless online or mobile experience can save you time, improve your trading efficiency and ensure you stay connected to the markets, no matter where you are.

5. Your investment goals are changing

As your financial situation and investment goals evolve, your current broker may no longer align with your needs.

Perhaps you’re transitioning from short-term trading to retirement-focused, long-term wealth building, or maybe you’re interested in more sophisticated strategies like margin trading, options or international investments. If your broker doesn’t offer the products, services or guidance that support your new objectives, it could hinder your progress.

A broker that once worked well for a specific strategy may not be equipped to help you meet your changing goals, whether you’re focusing more on retirement planning, tax-efficient investing or building a more diversified portfolio.

If your broker isn’t flexible enough to grow with you, switching to one that offers a wider range of investment products, better advisory services or tailored financial planning tools may provide more value in the long run.

How do you make the switch?

Making the switch to a new broker is simpler than you might think. Most brokerage firms that offer retirement accounts offer IRA transfers, which let you move funds between two IRAs of the same type without selling off assets and without incurring taxes or penalties.

  1. Start by researching and selecting an IRA provider that better meets your needs, considering factors like fees, investment options, tools and customer service. 
  2. Choose a new IRA provider, open an account and initiate an account transfer. 
  3. Wait for the transfer to move your entire IRA portfolio, or the eligible assets, directly from one broker to another, usually within a week or two. 
  4. Review any potential transfer or IRA closing fees your old broker may charge and check if your new broker offers reimbursement for these fees.

Before making the switch, review your financial plan and make sure your new IRA provider aligns with your long-term goals.

Our Editorial Standards

At ValueWalk, we’re committed to providing accurate, research-backed information. Our editors go above and beyond to ensure our content is trustworthy and transparent.

Matt Miczulski
Editor
Dividends

The Top Vanguard ETFs for Dividends

Dave Kovaleski11 hours

With concerns over market choppiness, investors can find good values in these excellent dividend ETFs. Dividend stocks and exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, are more popular investments when markets are volatile,...

Want Financial Guidance Sent Straight to You?

  • Pop your email in the box, and you'll receive bi-weekly emails from ValueWalk.
  • We never send spam — only the latest financial news and guides to help you take charge of your financial future.