Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA)’s mass market Generation III Model E is anticipated to hit the roads sometime in 2017. Tesla CEO Elon Musk has said that it will be a truly mass market car with a price tag of around $35,000. The car would have a gross margin of 15%, and will offer 200-mile range. But according to Stanphyl Capital Management, that looks more like a pipe dream.
Much of Tesla’s profits come from optional upgrades
For the fourth quarter 2013, Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) reported a net revenue of $761 million. It you exclude $13 million from Toyota Motor Corp (NYSE:TM) and Daimler AG (ETR:DAI) (FRA:DAI) (OTCMKTS:DDAIF) powertrain revenue, and another $15 million in regulatory credits, Model S sales generated $733 million. Divide that figure by 6892 cars, and you’ll get an average selling price (ASP) of $106,355 per car.
The following is our rough coverage of the 2021 Sohn Investment Conference, which is being held virtually and features Brad Gerstner, Bill Gurley, Octahedron's Ram Parameswaran, Glenernie's Andrew Nunneley, and Lux's Josh Wolfe. Q1 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more Keep checking back as we will be updating this post as the conference goes Read More
Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) earned 25.2% in non-GAAP gross margin on that $106,355 ASP, i.e., $26,801 per car. The basic Model S with 60kWh battery is priced at $70,000 excluding tax credits. Stanphyl Capital assumed that all upgrades above the basic price, i.e., $36,355 per car above the $70K price, generate 45% gross margin (35% margin on battery upgrades and 50% on other upgrades). That means $16,360 of Tesla’s $26,801 gross profit came from the battery and optional upgrades. That means the build cost of the most basic Model S is $59,559, and the gross margin is $10,441.
Elon Musk says that the Model S will be priced at $35,000. The most rumored numbers suggest that the battery costs $260/kWh. That means the battery of the Model S costs $15,600. The Model E is likely to have a 48kWh battery, which would cost $12,480. But the gigafactory should reduce the battery costs by about 35% to $8,112. So, Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) will be able to save ($15,600 – $8,112) $7,488 per Model E.
Tesla needs additional ways to preserve margins
Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) has to find sources of additional savings. Elon Musk has said that the Model E will be smaller than the current Model S. Stanphyl Capital Management estimates it would save about 400 pound/car in aluminum. At $0.75/pound, that generates $300 in savings per car. The Model E may also save 100 pounds in vinyls and over plastics. At $2/pound, that’s a $200 saving per car. The research firm says that producing the Model E is likely to require a lot of new tooling, because it won’t be able to use many of the Model S tools. Assuming there is at least some shared tooling, the electric vehicle maker can deduct an additional $100 per car in amortization costs. Tesla deducted $64 per car in amortization in 2013.
Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) can generate additional savings with smaller video screens, wheels, tires, and brakes. The research firm assumed this could add up to $400 in savings. Moreover, as the company grows, it will be able to negotiate better deals from component suppliers, which is projected to be a maximum of $3000 per car.
Will Tesla suffer a $13,000 loss per Model E?
The most basic Model S has a build cost of $59,559. Subtract $7488 in battery savings, $300 in aluminum savings, $200 in plastic savings, $164 in amortization savings, and $3000 in “bulk order” savings. So, the manufacturing cost of the most basic Model E would be around $48,007. So, how can Musk sell it for $35,000?
Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) shares were up 1.61% to $212.97 at 10:39 AM EST on Monday.