Speculation versus investment. It’s all a matter of semantics

Howard Marks Speculation versus investment. It’s all a matter of semantics.Editor’s Note: This is the first of several responses to the question “what is the difference between investment and speculation?” If you are If you are compelled, we invite you to comment below, tweet us @cfainvestored, or reach out to us via email.The word “speculation” is commonly applied to risky investments. And the word “risky” is usually used by the masses to describe investments in assets of low quality or uncertain outlook.

On the other hand, “safe investment” is commonly associated with assets of high quality and/or those with a positive outlook. However, because of these desirable characteristics, so-called “safe investments” usually sell at high prices. And high prices have the potential to turn high quality assets into risky investments.

The more insightful investor knows that:

Two Sigma’s Venn outlines factor performance for March

EuropeEquities did well last month as most market watchers have noted that Value outperformed growth. In his March Factor Performance report, Alex Botte of Venn by Two Sigma noted that March was a strong month for the global Equity factor, especially in developed markets. Q1 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more He said Europe Read More

  • “High quality” and “favorable outlook” are in no way synonymous with “good investment,” and certainly not with “safe investment.”
  • It’s easy to lose money on high-quality assets; people have been doing it for years.
  • Rather than quality, the greatest determinant of a safe (and profitable) investment is cheapness.
  • Buying high-quality assets at high prices can be very risky.
  • Low-quality speculations are usually looked down upon. But widespread derision usually results in low prices, which can make for high return potential (and good safety)
  • Thus buying low-priced low-quality assets can be very rewarding. They may be called rank speculations when they’re made, but they’re often relabeled astute investments when big profits are harvested.

Let me approach this another way: John Maynard Keynes said “a speculator is one who runs risks of which he is aware and an investor is one who runs risks of which he is unaware.” What did Keynes mean? Understanding him requires some of the complex, counter-intuitive thinking that must be present if investing is to be understood.

  • People who buy obviously risky assets may be called speculators.
  • People who buy seemingly safe assets are likely to be called investors. But they usually pay prices commensurate with the assets’ apparent risklessness, and when unanticipated risks surface, they can come as a big – and unhappy – surprise. Unfavorable surprises tend to produce investment losses.

I think of investment results as what happens when reality collides with expectations. So-called “speculative” assets are usually the subject of low expectations on the part of the investing crowd. If those expectations are exceeded, profits can result.

But high quality investments are often premised on lofty expectations, and these are subject to disappointment. When that occurs, “investments” can turn out to have carried “risks of which the investor was unaware.”

That’s what Keynes meant. By his standard, I’d much rather be an intelligent speculator than a conventional investor.

Howard Marks, CFA. This was previously published on Inside Investing at the CFA Institute.

Inside Investing at CFA Institute is a forum for delivering actionable insights on current issues in finance and investing. The blog is written by CFA Charterholders for a wide audience and aims to elevate interesting and compelling opinions, educate the public about investment topics, and give practical tools for investors to use.

By delivering useful and practical insights, Inside Investing supports and extends the mission of CFA Institute, the global association of investment professionals, which strives to lead the investment profession globally by setting the highest standards of ethics, education, and professional excellence.

For queries about the blog, please contact the editors.

 Please note that the content of this site should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute.

About Howard Marks, CFA

Howard Marks is the Chairman of Oaktree Capital, an investment firm in Los Angeles, and author of “The Most Important Thing,” a book on his investment philosophy that was published in 2011.

Previous article Apple Inc. (AAPL) Is In Need Of Another ‘Creative Leap’: Ex CEO
Next article Nokia Corporation (ADR) (NOK) Lumia 720 & 520 Prices Revealed
The CFA Institute Enterprising Investor blog is a forum for delivering practical analysis of current issues in finance and investing. The blog is written for investment professionals and aims to elevate the most interesting and compelling commentary and perspectives from the sea of opinions and research; to contextualize the many educational offerings of CFA Institute; and to provoke debate and an exchange of ideas among serious investment practitioners about topics of the day. The CFA Institute Market Integrity Insights blog is a forum for providing analysis and commentary on the integrity of global capital markets. From regulatory reform and corporate governance to insider trading and financial reporting, our content experts explore timely issues in financial regulation and other issues affecting the global capital markets. In addition, CFA Institute publishes a variety of blogs covering our live events programming around the world, including the CFA Institute Annual Conference, now in its 65th year; the European Investment Conference; the Middle East Investment Conference; and the Asia Pacific Investment Conference. Please note that the content of these blogs should not be construed as investment advice, nor do the opinions expressed necessarily reflect the views of CFA Institute.

No posts to display