by Gary D. Halbert

November 1, 2016

  1. 3Q Advance GDP Report Came in Stronger Than Expected
  2. Which US Presidents Have Been Best For the Economy
  3. Global Bond Markets Suffer Worst Losses Since 2013
  4. Odds of Fed Interest Rate Hike in December Are Increasing


We will touch on several bases today. I must admit that it was so tempting to devote today’s E-Letter to a discussion about the presidential election one week from today, especially with all the recent twists and turns in this race.

But the fact is, these are two of the worst presidential candidates I can ever remember. So I’ll spare you my political thoughts today. I do have an interesting section below on which US presidents have been best for the economy dating back to President Eisenhower in 1953. Hint: President Obama ranks dead last!

[drizzle]Following that discussion, we’ll take a look at the global bond market which has taken a hit over the last couple of months. Bonds worldwide lost almost 3% in October alone, the largest monthly loss since May 2013. The question is whether this is just a “correction” or the beginning of a new trend?

Before we get into those discussions, let’s take a look at last Friday’s stronger than expected GDP report for the 3Q. The advance report showed growth well above the pre-report consensus. Most analysts concluded that the door is now wide open for the Fed to raise short-term interest rates in December. I’ll give you my latest thoughts as we go along today.

3Q Advance GDP Report Came in Stronger Than Expected

The US economy grew at its fastest pace in two years in the third quarter as a surge in exports and a rebound in inventory investment offset a slowdown in consumer spending. Business investment improved last quarter, although spending on equipment remained weak.

Gross domestic product increased 2.9% (annual rate) in the 3Q after rising at a 1.4% pace in the 2Q, the Commerce Department said on Friday in its first of three estimates.  The pre-report consensus called for a rise of 2.5%, so the advance report was better than expected. That was the strongest growth rate since the 3Q of 2014.

Over the first half of the year, GDP growth had averaged just 1.1%, and some forecasters feared that we might be headed for a recession. Those fears have largely disappeared after Friday’s better than expected GDP report.

GDP Report

GDP Report

Consumer spending which accounts for almost 70% of GDP rose only 2.1% in the 3Q, down from the robust increase of 4.3% in the 2Q. Yet despite the moderation in consumer spending, the 3Q rise of 2.9% in GDP dispelled any lingering fears the economy was at risk of stalling. But not all the news on consumer spending was bad.

Consumer spending on long-lasting durable goods, such as cars and appliances, rose by better than 9% in the past two quarters. Yet overall spending was held back by a decline in purchases of goods which are not meant to last long (non-durable goods). With a tightening labor market generating increases in wages and strong household balance sheets, spending could accelerate in the 4Q, analysts suggested.

Exports, which add to GDP, increased at a 10% rate in the 3Q, the best gain in nearly three years. Export gains had slumped over the prior year and a half, in part because a stronger dollar made US goods more expensive overseas.

Friday’s GDP report gave voters their last comprehensive look at the economy’s health before the November election. The improvement could give Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton more latitude to position herself as the candidate to continue Obama administration policies that have led to a long  expansion.

Still, the most recent gain comes in the weakest expansion in recent memory, a point Republican candidate Donald Trump makes frequently. Since the recession ended in mid-2009, the economy has grown at just under a 2.0% annual rate, making the current expansion the weakest on record dating back to 1949.

In fact, if we look at the same GDP data on a rolling 12-month basis, the economy continues to falter. Even if the 4Q produces close to 3% growth again, the full-year GDP growth rate for 2016 is likely to be around 2.0%, even lower than the anemic 2.4% growth rate in 2015.

GDP Report

This is not a pretty picture! Keep in mind that Friday’s advance GDP report was the first of three such estimates which will be revised again (up or down) at the end of November and December.

Which US Presidents Have Been Best For the Economy

With one of the most important presidential elections in our lifetimes just one week away, and with two of the most polarizing and controversial candidates in recent memory, the US economy remains issue #1 for most Americans.

With that in mind, I thought we would take a look today at which US presidents in recent history have been the best and worst for the economy among the last 11 occupants of the White House. We judge them by the average quarterly GDP growth while in office dating back to 1953.

President John F. Kennedy ranks #1 on the list. President Kennedy, while a Democrat, had a very conservative, pro-growth agenda consisting of tax cuts for businesses and lower marginal income tax rates across the board. His tax reductions were aimed at increasing incentives for work, saving and investment.

Kennedy’s business tax cuts became law in 1962, and his tax decreases on personal income were enacted in 1964, just a few months after his assassination. The changes in economic behavior that accompanied his policies were among the most rejuvenating and long-lasting in the post-World War II era. The economy grew at a rate of 5.5% on President Kennedy’s watch.

President Lyndon B. Johnson was smart enough to continue Kennedy’s pro-growth policies for the most part during his presidency from 1963 to 1969. The economy grew at a rate of 5.1% on President Johnson’s watch.

GDP Report

Source: U.S. News & World Report, Commerce Department
President William J. Clinton is third on the list with average economic growth of 3.8% during his two terms from 1993 to 2001. Clinton presided over the longest peacetime economic expansion in American history. In 1993, Clinton cut taxes for 15 million low-income families, made tax cuts available to 90% of small businesses and raised taxes on the wealthiest 1.2% of taxpayers – which he was most known for.

In 1997, the Republican-led Congress passed a tax-relief and deficit-reduction bill that was initially resisted but ultimately signed by President Clinton. That bill lowered the top capital gains tax rate from 28% to 20%, created a new $500 child tax credit, established tax credits for higher education, created the Roth IRA, etc. Clinton later acknowledged that the tax cuts were a benefit for the economy.

President Ronald Reagan is next on the list with average economic growth of 3.6% during his two terms from 1981 to 1989. Ronald Reagan’s presidency was propelled by pro-growth tax cuts and deregulation. Gross Domestic Product soared by 34% during his eight years in office.

President Barack H. Obama ranks last on

1, 2  - View Full Page