Finding Value In Declining Commodity Prices

Finding Value In Declining Commodity Prices

Finding Value in Declining Commodity Prices by Frank Holmes

I’m going to begin with a bit of good news. Below is our China Region Fund (USCOX). As you can see, not only has it broken above its 50- and 200-day moving averages, but it’s also trading at four-year highs. And since this chart was created earlier in the week, the fund has climbed even higher.

As I mentioned last week, USCOX has benefited from the continued rally in the Shanghai Composite Index through our holdings in the Morgan Stanley China A Share Fund and a closed-end fund. The Shanghai Composite is up 87 percent year-over-year and is currently at a seven-year high.

Short-Seller Spruce Point Highlights Its Latest Canadian Consumer Short: Saputo

InvestReputed short-seller Spruce Point Capital Management released its latest short report this week. The firm is shorting Canadian dairy and grocery manufacturer Saputo. Spruce Point chief Ben Axler believes the company is entering a phase of declining growth and highlights the financial stress and growing challenges he sees it facing, not only in Canada but Read More

Commodity Prices

So what’s the deal with Chinese equities right now? After all, China’s economic growth for the first quarter of the year cooled to a six-year low of 7 percent.

The market surge is mostly attributable to monetary easing and government policy changes such as housing stimulus and modernization of the country’s financial structure. But there’s more at work.

Saving Big on Commodities Slump

Also contributing to the bull run is the plunge in commodity prices since last June, brought on by both the strong U.S. dollar and a slowing global economy.

Such market conditions have obviously been a challenge for those involved in the production of raw materials and natural resources. But they’ve been a windfall for net-import countries, China included. Most of the beneficiaries are Asian and Eastern European nations—excluding Russia, whose economy largely depends on revenue generated from oil exports.

Besides Russia, the biggest losers have been Latin American countries, huge exporters of some of the hardest-hit resources—crude oil, sugar, soybeans and coffee.

Commodity Prices

As the world’s largest importer of natural resources, China saves an estimated $600 million a day on its oil import bill. That’s a staggering $200 billion a year. Low oil prices, in fact, should help boost GDP growth in the entire Asia-Pacific region between 0.25 and 0.5 percent, according to Rajiv Biswas, economist at consulting firm IHS Inc.

Low oil prices are also helping many businesses and companies such as American Airlines keep more capital in their coffers. For every $1 change in oil, American saves about $105 million per month in jet fuel costs, according to airline research analyst Helane Becker of financial services firm Cowen Group.

Amazingly enough, precious metals are the best-performing commodities sub-sector so far this year, having collectively lost 2.5 percent.

Commodity Prices

Of the 29 resources featured in the chart above, only red meat is in the black.

Finding Value In Declining Commodity PricesWhereas many of these commodities are facing oversupply issues, the cattle industry as well as barbeque purveyors are currently struggling with a brisket shortage, which have driven the wholesale price of the popular cut of meat up 60 percent from last year. Several barbeque joints here in San Antonio, in fact, have fallen victim this year to what the media are calling “the brisket bandit,” who’s made off with thousands of dollars’ worth of meat, both raw and smoked.

Platinum and palladium are fundamentally undervalued right now, and demand for both metals is expected to pick up this year. Low prices should spur platinum jewelry demand in China, while an increase in automobile sales in the U.S., eurozone and China should help palladium. (Palladium is used in the production of catalytic converters.)

The Start of Mergers and Acquisitions

The challenging crude oil environment has prompted the first of what will likely be a new wave of oil and gas company mergers and acquisitions (M&As) similar to what we last saw in the late 1990s. If you recall, Exxon merged with Mobil in an $80-billion deal, BP tied the knot with Amoco and Chevron bought Texaco.

Commodity PricesThe current cycle kicked off last November when titan Halliburton agreed to purchase Baker Hughes for $35 billion.

Now, for double that price in cash and stock, Royal Dutch Shell plans to gobble up UK-based BG Group in the biggest deal since the Exxon-Mobil merger. The combined companies will become the world’s largest producer of liquefied natural gas (LNG). Shell’s oil and gas reserves will grow 25 percent and give the company huge exposure to proven oilfields in Australia and Brazil. As is normally the case, the company being acquired sees a spike in share price, and BG is no exception; this week alone, its stock has risen more than 30 percent.

It’s doubtful we’ll see a deal this round as massive as Exxon-Mobil, but we expect more to occur among the junior to mid-tier producers and explorers.

Remembering Paul Reynolds

Today I’m in Toronto celebrating the life of my friend Paul Reynolds, premier broker in the resource world and former president and CEO of Canaccord Genuity, Canada’s largest independent investment bank. He passed away in Hawaii last Thursday following his competition in the Lavaman Waikoloa triathlon. He was 52.

Paul was an early pioneer in the London Alternative Investment Market (AIM), which was a very successful platform for the creation of new companies, especially those involved in natural resources. During his tenure as chief executive, he turned Canaccord into a global operation through his balance of collaboration and competition. Besides being a highly-respected and transformative brokerage executive, my friend had an infectious zest for life. He was a seasoned participant in Olympic-length triathlons and other physically-demanding competitions.

Paul is survived by his wife, four children, and a large, tightknit extended family. They, along with his abundance of friends and colleagues, will remember the profound impact of his larger than life charisma and big heart. Paul will be deeply missed. ­

Total Annualized Returns as of 03/31/2015
  One-Year Five-Year Ten-Year Gross
China Region Fund 6.63% 0.52% 5.14% 2.77% 2.55%

Expense ratios as stated in the most recent prospectus. The expense cap is a voluntary limit on total fund operating expenses (exclusive of any acquired fund fees and expenses, performance fees, taxes, brokerage commissions and interest) that U.S. Global Investors, Inc. can modify or terminate at any time, which may lower a fund’s yield or return. Performance data quoted above is historical. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Results reflect the reinvestment of dividends and other earnings. For a portion of periods, the fund had expense limitations, without which returns would have been lower. Current performance may be higher or lower than the performance data quoted. The principal value and investment return of an investment will fluctuate so that your shares, when redeemed, may be worth more or less than their original cost. Performance does not include the effect of any direct fees described in the fund’s prospectus which, if applicable, would lower your total returns. Performance quoted for periods of one year or less is cumulative and not annualized. Obtain performance data current to the most recent month-end at or 1-800-US-FUNDS.

Index Summary

  • The major market indices finished higher this week.  The Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 1.66 percent. The S&P 500 Stock Index also gained 1.70 percent, while the Nasdaq Composite advanced 2.23 percent. The Russell 2000 small capitalization index rose 0.73 percent this week.
  • The Hang Seng Composite gained 8.98 percent this week; while Taiwan rose 0.18 percent and the KOSPI advanced 2.89 percent.
  • The 10-year Treasury bond yield rose 4 basis points to 1.95 percent.

Domestic Equity Market

The S&P 500 roared higher this week rising by 1.70 percent. Economically sensitive sectors led the way with industrials, energy and technology particularly strong performers. Interest rate sensitive areas of the market tended to underperform even though bond yields didn’t make any dramatic moves higher.

Commodity Prices


  • The industrials sector was the best performer this week, led by General Electric which rose by more than 14 percent as the company announced a restricting plan that included exiting most of the company’s lending and real estate operations and simultaneously announcing a massive $50 billion stock buyback.
  • The energy sector was also a strong performer in the S&P 500 as almost every stock in the index rose this week. The sector was led by the offshore drillers, Transocean, Noble Corp, Ensco and Diamond Offshore. These stocks have been laggards and caught up some this week but with oil still mired around $50, near-term business prospects will still be weak.
  • Perrigo was the best performer in the S&P 500, rising 21.27 percent this week but closely trailed by Mylan, which rose 20.91 percent. On Wednesday, Mylan made an unsolicited offer for Perrigo at a 23 percent premium and unusually both stocks rallied substantially on the news.


  • While every sector in the S&P 500 was positive for the week there were pockets of weakness. REITs underperformed, with many REIT areas falling by 2.5-3 percent on rising interest rate fears.  The homebuilders suffered a similar fate for the same reason.
  • Other areas of weakness included Bed Bath & Beyond which reported disappointing results and outlook. Freeport-McMoran was also weak on concerns of Chinese weakness in the mining sector.
  • Hudson City Bancorp was the worst performer in the S&P 500 this week, falling 8.67 percent. The company is in the process of being acquired by M&T Bank, which said regulators won’t be able to complete a review of the proposed transaction by the April 30 deadline.


  • The first-quarter earnings season kicks into high gear next week with JP Morgan, Intel, Goldman Sachs, Schlumberger and many more reporting next week.
  • A strong dollar continues to benefit domestic consumers, maintaining an advantage for certain U.S.-focused retailers and consumer products.
  • The market ended the week on a positive note and the bull market just keeps moving forward.


  • The consumer appears confident but recent data points indicate some unexpected conservatism that could weigh on growth prospects.
  • Biotechnology companies have been market darlings but may be showing their age.
  • The Federal Reserve still appears to be on track for a late summer rate hike.

The Economy and Bond Market

U.S. Treasury bond yields moved higher this week as equities rallied and uncertainty over the timing of possible Fed tightening reversed last week’s gains. The employment report which was released on Good Friday showed unexpected weakness, but the market closed on Monday not far from Thursday’s close, so the market more or less just shrugged it off.

Commodity Prices


  • Job openings hit a 14-year high in February, which is another piece of evidence confirming the 5.5 percent unemployment rate and strengthening job market.
  • Mortgage applications rose for the third week in a row and are at the highest level in almost two years.
  • Auto sales in China rose 3.3 percent in March vs. a year ago to 2.24 million vehicles.


  • States with a concentration in the energy sector are seeing deteriorating economic optimism which may accelerate if other sectors can’t pick up the slack.
  • Wholesale inventories rose 0.3 percent in February and remain at an elevated level relative to sales and are a potential early warning sign that the economy may be at risk.
  • The U.S. dollar rallied against major currencies this week, potentially resuming the strong trend that began last year. The strong dollar is already having a negative impact on the export oriented manufacturing sector and could act as even more of a brake on the economy than many are currently expecting.


  • European economic data is already on the mend and QE will just add fuel to the fire.
  • China remains in monetary easing mode and more stimulus is likely.
  • U.S. bond yields remain the highest in the developed world and funds will likely continue to flow into U.S. fixed income.


  • One of the themes from the recent earnings season was that the strong U.S. dollar has negatively impacted companies’ bottom lines and capital spending plans. This will likely be the case for the first quarter as well. This negative impact could be seen this week in weak manufacturing data.
  • The Fed seems almost determined to raise interest rates irrespective of the near term economic performance, raising the risk of a policy error.
  • With a global easing cycle underway, global economic growth expectations have already started to improve, making it an easier decision for the Fed to possibly raise rates.

Gold Market

Since the Thursday before Good Friday, spot gold closed at $1,208.35, up $5.75 per ounce, or 0.48 percent. Gold stocks, as measured by the NYSE Arca Gold Miners Index, gained 2.23 percent. The U.S. Trade-Weighted Dollar Index gained 1.95 percent over the extended holiday period.

Date Event Survey Actual Prior
Apr-9 U.S. Initial Jobless Claims 283K 281K 268K
Apr-14 U.S. PPI Final Demand YoY -0.90% -0.60%
Apr-14 Chinese Retail Sales YoY 10.90%
Apr-15 German CPI YoY 0.30% 0.30%
Apr-15 ECB Main Refinancing Rate 0.05% 0.05%
Apr-16 U.S. Housing Starts 1040K 897K
Apr-16 U.S. Initial Jobless Claims 280K 281K
Apr-17 EU CPI Core YoY 0.60% 0.60%
Apr-17 U.S. CPI YoY 0.00% 0.00%


  • Gold rose for the first time in four days on Friday after holdings in exchange-traded products (ETPs) backed by bullion saw the largest increase in more than six weeks. Silver rose the most in a week.
  • March gold imports for India came in at about 125 tons versus 60 tons a year ago. Furthermore, year-to-date (YTD) imports are at about 900 tons versus 662 tons the previous year.
  • Several companies released positive drilling results and production updates this week. Klondex Mines announced that one of the veins drilled in its Midas Phase I program yielded 280.3 g/t of gold equivalent to over 1.5 meters. Lake Shore Gold’s first quarter preliminary gold production came in at 53,000 ounces, up 19 percent year-over-year. St. Barbara announced record gold production of 111,288 ounces in the first quarter of the year. Lastly, Claude Resources also set a quarterly record with production of 21,067 ounces.


  • Federal Reserve policy minutes released this week from their most recent meeting showed officials were split last month over whether they would raise interest rates in June. Short sellers used this as an opportunity to push gold down for a third day.
  • Armed robbers walked away with an estimated $8.5 million of gold from the refinery at McEwen Mining’s El Gallo 1 Mine in Mexico’s Sinaloa state on Tuesday. The gold was contained in an estimated 900 kilograms of gold-bearing concentrate. The company announced that while it is insured, the policy won’t be enough to cover the entire expected loss. Apparently the furnace to produce the doré bars was offline for repairs, thus causing the gold concentrate to build up. This hints at the robbery being an inside job, with someone with knowledge of the buildup likely tipping off an outsider.
  • Norilsk sees South African output of platinum declining in the next several years. With output already falling, however, it is troubling that there has not been a positive price response.

Commodity Prices

Commodity Prices

Furthermore, looking at the grade that has been processed (head grade) versus reserve grade, companies are currently processing close to reserve grade. Over the last five years, the average head grade is within 2 percent of reserve grade. Head grade in general has been seeing a decline in values since 2001 but dropped abruptly in 2005, forcing companies to struggle to keep their operations profitable.

  • In a new report, RBC Capital Markets analysts identify three phases gold miners have historically gone through in response to low commodity prices: rationalization, restructuring and refinancing. Their view is that we are still in the rationalization phase, when management teams think prices will recover in the near term. Given this outlook, they respond to market conditions with “temporary fixes” such as cuts to sustaining capital. However, as we move into the restructuring phase, there is an uptick in insolvencies and mergers, and in the refinancing phase, optimism ticks up and well-financed companies try to consolidate mining camps. The RBC analysts believe these latter phases are coming soon.
  • Goldman Sachs published a report warning that capex cuts could threaten future production. In response to the multiyear commodity price correction, gold miners globally have cut capex by 52 percent since year-end 2012, which Goldman forecasts will drive a 7-percent decline in production by 2018 from today’s levels.
  • Bank of America/Merrill Lynch published a report in which they argue that while producers have been focused on maximizing free cash flow from operations, there is a concern that not enough attention is being paid to the declining reserves trend. The average reserve life index for the North American gold producers has plunged 23 percent from 13 years ago at year-end 2012 to 10.2 years at year-end 2014.
  • This relates to a study from Scotiabank, illustrated in the chart above, that argues the decline in reserves in 2014 came about mainly because companies did not replace depletion as the gold price used for reserve analysis was flat.


  • India is the world’s biggest consumer of gold, and its ancient temples have collected billions of dollars in jewelry, bars and coins over the centuries which are hidden securely in vaults. Now the government plans to get its hands on this temple of gold, estimated at about 3,000 tons, to help tackle India’s chronic trade imbalance. Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government is planning to launch a scheme in May that would encourage temples to deposit their gold with banks in return for interest payments. The government would melt the gold and loan it to jewelers to meet an insatiable appetite for gold and reduce economically crippling gold imports. Key to Modi’s plan will be the interest rates offered for gold deposits. If India can cut imports, that would pressure gold prices that fell to a four-month low last month before recovering.
  • In Greece, hundreds of supporters and opponents of Eldorado Gold’s mining operation clashed despite police efforts to separate them. Police said more than 2,000 supporters and 850 opponents were involved. The mine operation has sharply divided residents, with some fearing environmental damage and a drop in tourism. Others welcome the nearly 2,000 jobs it provides at a time of economic crisis.
  • The Greek energy minister derided Eldorado Gold, saying the company “can’t act like a state within a state.” It said the government won’t be blackmailed and condemned the blocking of roads by Eldorado workers during Easter period.

Energy and Natural Resources Market

Commodity Prices


  • Oil and gas drilling stocks outperformed this week alongside a nice bounce in crude oil prices. WTI crude rose 5.37 percent this week, while the S&P Supercomposite Oil & Gas Drilling Index rose 7.15 percent.
  • Tanker stocks continued their rally this week as global growth prospects continued to strengthen due to global easing. The Bloomberg News Tanker Index rose 5.46 percent this week.
  • Canadian metals and mining stocks outperformed this week as investors expect more action out of China to stimulate growth. The S&P/TSX Diversified Capped Metals and Mining Index rose 3.39 percent this week.


  • Utilities stocks were a relative underperformer as investors poured into more cyclical areas. The S&P 500 Utilities Index rose 0.20 percent this week.
  • Construction materials stocks, which had a significant bounce in February, were a relative laggard this week. The S&P Supercomposite Construction and Materials Index rose 0.36 percent this week.
  • Oil and gas refiners were a relative underperformer this week as the gap between WTI and Brent crude oil continued to shrink. The S&P Supercomposite Oil & Gas Refining & Marketing Index rose 0.55 percent this week.


  • Copper prices are trying to breaking out of the bear market the commodity experienced in the back half of 2014. Further economic stimulus from China and globally should boost the struggling commodity.
  • The global environment has all but fully evolved into an easing one. Multiple countries have cut interest rates or stimulated their economies through other means over the past few months, leading to a more synchronized growth strategy. If successful, these government policies should aid commodity demand.
  • The Baker Hughes United States crude oil rig count fell again this week to 760. With the rig count continuing to fall, it is only a matter of time before crude oil begins its steady rise.


  • The dollar rose every single day this week, disrupting what could have potentially been the beginning of a downward cycle. The dollar closed up 2.93 percent this week.
  • The Iran framework deal creates more uncertainty surrounding the global supply of crude oil and, if not offset by production cuts elsewhere, could cause oil prices to retreat.
  • Natural gas, in sharp contrast to crude oil, has failed to see any sign of a shift in momentum as prices continue to fall due to an unfavorable weather outlook.

Emerging Markets


  • Chinese H-shares had a tremendous run this week as they raced to catch up with their A-share counterparts, on expectations of further stimulus from the government. The Hang Seng Composite Index rose 8.98 percent this week.
  • Hungarian equities continued to be a strong relative outperformer as the country received residual benefits from the eurozone’s easing program. The Budapest Stock Exchange Index rose 5.75 percent this week.
  • Indian equities rallied this week as February’s industrial production data rose 5 percent against an expected 3 percent increase. The S&P BSE Sensex Index rose 2.19 percent this week.


  • Russian equities underperformed this week despite a rally in the ruble and crude oil. The MICEX Index fell 1.45 percent this week.
  • Turkish equities and the Lira continued their downward trend this week as the country’s growth outlook remained disappointing and investors continue to fear the coming rate hike in the United States. The Borsa Istanbul 100 Index fell 0.42 percent this week while the lira fell 2.27 percent.
  • Emerging European currencies continued to decline as the European Central Bank’s stimulus program floods the region with liquidity. The Hungarian forint, the Czech koruna and the Polish zloty fell 2.72, 2.90, and 2.48 percent, respectively, against the dollar this week.


Commodity Prices

  • Bloomberg released a report detailing how cheap Turkish banks are relative to other emerging market financial companies in terms of price-to-book ratios. While this relatively cheap valuation of Turkish banks could be an opportunity to buy cheap quality companies it should be carefully considered.
  • Many Asia analysts are forecasting further rate cuts out of Thailand as a response to declining exports and deflationary pressures. Further stimulus in the regions should be positive for synchronized global growth.
  • Moody’s Investors Service and Fitch Ratings elevated their respective growth forecasts for India this week. Both rating agencies maintain an investment grade for India and expect the government led reforms to positively impact economic growth.


  • The dollar’s rally is weighing on Poland as foreign investors dump their holdings of zloty-denominated assets. The government still requires 43 percent of the funding required for 2015, leaving the assets vulnerable to any further decline in demand for government debt.
  • Deutsche Bank is predicting the euro will reach parity with the dollar by the end of this year and fall to 90 cents in 2016. Divergence in monetary policy, according to the bank, should continue to weigh on the euro relative to the dollar.

Leaders and Laggards

Weekly Performance
Index Close Weekly
DJIA 18,057.65 +294.41 +1.66%
S&P 500 2,102.06 +35.10 +1.70%
S&P Energy 585.36 +17.57 +3.09%
S&P Basic Materials 311.81 +4.58 +1.49%
Nasdaq 4,995.98 +109.04 +2.23%
Russell 2000 1,264.76 +9.11 +0.73%
Hang Seng Composite Index 3,838.14 +316.33 +8.98%
Korean KOSPI Index 2,087.76 +58.69 +2.89%
S&P/TSX Canadian Gold Index 165.88 +3.68 +2.27%
XAU 69.27 +1.31 +1.93%
Gold Futures 1,207.70 +6.80 +0.57%
Oil Futures 51.73 +2.59 +5.27%
Natural Gas Futures 2.51 -0.20 -7.45%
10-Yr Treasury Bond 1.95 +0.04 +2.04%


Monthly Performance
Index Close Monthly
DJIA 18,057.65 +422.26 +2.39%
S&P 500 2,102.06 +61.82 +3.03%
S&P Energy 585.36 +35.39 +6.43%
S&P Basic Materials 311.81 +0.61 +0.20%
Nasdaq 4,995.98 +146.04 +3.01%
Russell 2000 1,264.76 +48.99 +4.03%
Hang Seng Composite Index 3,838.14 -332.01 -14.83%
Korean KOSPI Index 2,087.76 +106.93 +5.40%
S&P/TSX Canadian Gold Index 165.88 +6.90 +4.34%
XAU 69.27 +3.30 +5.00%
Gold Futures 1,207.70 +56.10 +4.87%
Oil Futures 51.73 +3.56 +7.39%
Natural Gas Futures 2.51 -0.31 -11.08%
10-Yr Treasury Bond 1.95 -0.16 -7.49%


Quarterly Performance
Index Close Quarterly
DJIA 18,057.65 +320.28 +1.81%
S&P 500 2,102.06 +57.25 +2.80%
S&P Energy 585.36 +17.44 +3.07%
S&P Basic Materials 311.81 +7.74 +2.55%
Nasdaq 4,995.98 +291.91 +6.21%
Russell 2000 1,264.76 +79.09 +6.67%
Hang Seng Composite Index 3,838.14 +524.54 +15.83%
Korean KOSPI Index 2,087.76 +163.06 +8.47%
S&P/TSX Canadian Gold Index 165.88 -0.36 -0.22%
XAU 69.27 -6.90 -9.06%
Gold Futures 1,207.70 -9.90 -0.81%
Oil Futures 51.73 +3.37 +6.97%
Natural Gas Futures 2.51 -0.44 -14.77%
10-Yr Treasury Bond 1.95 +0.01 +0.26%

Please consider carefully a fund’s investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses.   For this and other important information, obtain a fund prospectus by visiting or by calling 1-800-US-FUNDS (1-800-873-8637).   Read it carefully before investing.  Distributed by U.S. Global Brokerage, Inc.

No posts to display