Standard & Poor’s has alleged that the ongoing lawsuit brought against it by the U.S. Justice Department was initiated in response to the 2011 downgrade the financial services company brought to bear on U.S. debt.
In a court filing picked up by The Wall Street Journal, Standard & Poors alleged that the law suit was brought against the company in “retaliation” for the downgrade of the United States’ debt back just over two years ago. The ratings agency removed the top class AAA rating from United States’ debt, moving down one place to a AA+ rating.
Stone House Capital Partners returned 4.1% for September, bringing its year-to-date return to 72% net. The S&P 500 is up 14.3% for the first nine months of the year. Q3 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more Stone House follows a value-based, long-long term and concentrated investment approach focusing on companies rather than the market Read More
DOJ suit unconstitutional
The filing from Standard & Poor’s said that the DOJ lawsuit was in direct retaliation to the downgrade, and that made the lawsuit unconstitutional. The filing asked for the case to be thrown out of court on that basis. According to the filing, the downgrade was an example of the company using its right for Free Speech.
“Such free speech is protected under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and the retaliation, causing and embodied in the commencement of this impermissibly selective, punitive and meritless litigation, is unconstitutional,” said the filing made with the California court today.
The filing suggests that Standard & Poor’s will concentrate on the political elements of the lawsuit in its defense against the DOJ. The agency previously tried to have the case thrown out on the basis that the Department of Justice was misrepresenting the way the firm rated financial instruments.
That appeal to have the case thrown out was turned down in July after the judge in charge of the case, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter of California, said that the defense was “deeply and unavoidably troubling.”
Standard & Poor’s target of DOJ
The Department of Justice lawsuit was filed last February and relates to the ratings given by S&P to mortgage backed securities and other financial instruments in the years leading up to the financial crisis. The lawsuit says that S&P committed fraud by obfuscating the process by which it applied ratings to different instruments, tricking financial institutions into buying the instruments.
The Department of Justice specifically calls Standard & Poor’s out on misrepresenting the instruments to federally backed insurers and credit unions, the institutions that the government of the United States had to spend billions bailing out of financial trouble during the crisis.