US Election 2020: Trump OK, Biden OK, But Neither Not OK

Chief Strategist of leading investment research and consultancy firm Edison Group Alastair George has conducted an in-depth analysis of the likely impact of the potential outcomes of the US election 2020 – possibly one of the most important elections in generations in terms of deciding the future direction of the country and in terms of economies and markets across the world.

Get The Full Ray Dalio Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Ray Dalio in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues

Q3 2020 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

He warns that we could be heading for a perfect storm for economies and markets: a combination of no US election result, a No Deal Brexit, and the acceleration of COVID leading to continued lockdowns. Investors need to brace for this impact.

Crispin Odey is preparing for inflation with a new fund

In a presentation for the Odey Inflation Fund, which was reviewed by ValueWalk, Crispin Odey's team made a case for how to protect yourself from inflation and discussed why gold isn't the best protection and how important it is to prepare for inflation in your portfolio. Q3 2020 hedge fund letters, conferences and more Protecting Read More


US election 2020: Political / Economic impact

  • Difference between Trump and Biden wafer thin– Despite the polarisation of US politics, economically speaking the difference between a Trump or Biden is slim. Worst outcome would be a drawn-out legal battle over the result which could plunge the US into paralysis.
  • Greater impact onforeign rather than domestic policy – Unconstrained by Congress, Trump was active in exercising power through foreign policy, while domestic policy is largely constrained by the current fiscal position of the US and constitutional checks and balances. A Biden win results in a more predictable foreign policy agenda.
  • Biden’s tax plans won’treally move the needle – Amounting to approximately 3% of US GDP, Biden’s Tax Plan doesn’t significantly differ from current policies. The main difference of a Biden win for the rest of the world lies in a less business friendly domestic policy agenda.
  • Green agenda will receive a boost– Trump’s foot-dragging climate change policies would cease to be relevant if Biden wins.
  • Impact on UK modesteither way – At least compared to the impact of COVID-19 and Brexit.

Developed/Developing Markets impact

  • Biden winmeans fewer bouts of risk aversion in global markets – Biden will continue to fight for the long-term US interest in relation to China and its trade practices, but in a less confrontational and more strategic manner. This will calm global markets, which obsessed over the result of US/China trade negotiations over most of 2019.
  • Europeanand developing market equities likely to perform better – If he wins, Biden isn’t likely to tout the stock market as a gauge of his success. US corporate tax increases and a less ‘business-first’ approach opens the possibility of relatively better performance of European equities and higher beta segments such as emerging markets, especially if trade tensions ease with historic allies.
  • Big tech and fiscal stimulus package decisions loom– Any new administration’s views on competition policy could have an impact on “big tech” stocks, while outstanding issue of a fiscal stimulus package to address COVID-19 effects for 2021 still needs to be addressed, which weighs on US equity markets.
  • Froma markets perspective, Trump has been a highly intrusive US President – many investors would welcome a calmer political period.

US Election 2020: Trump OK, Biden OK, But Neither Not OK

Within the next week, a very unusual US Presidential election will take place. A significant proportion of voters will not go to polls, but instead due to coronavirus restrictions will send their ballots in by mail. Polls currently indicate that Biden’s lead remains in place in the closing stages of the race and this is the most likely outcome in our view. But there remains a significant chance of a contested election and weeks, if not months, of legal uncertainty. There may still be time for Biden’s lead to diminish into polling day although a clear Trump win at this point looks the least likely outcome.

The Strategic Challenge From China

Investors may be rightfully focussed on other risks at present with developed market GDP still so far below potential due to the fight against COVID-19. The timing of a vaccine and the interplay of monetary and fiscal support over the coming 12 months is likely to be the more important factor for global markets in our view. Nevertheless, the outcome of the US election 2020 will set the tone for US economic and foreign policy at a critical juncture, given the strategic challenge from China.

In the short term and in policy respects there will be little to choose between the candidates. We believe markets would take a second term for Trump with limited initial reaction, having become habituated to the volatility in foreign policy but combined with a business-friendly US domestic agenda.

Furthermore, both Biden and Trump will need to tackle the outstanding issue of a fiscal stimulus package to address COVID-19 effects for 2021. Further out, should Biden become President we would expect modestly higher US corporate tax rates which may weigh on sentiment for US equities which have had an exceptionally good crisis. This is especially notable when compared to the relatively weak performance of other developed and emerging markets.

Reducing The Monopoly Of The Technology Franchises

A Democrat President may also look favourably on reducing the alleged monopoly power of the largest US technology franchises. Given the large weighting of these stocks within US indices, this would be a further negative for US markets. On the other hand, the green agenda would receive a boost as Trump’s foot-dragging climate change policies would cease to be relevant.

Biden would also in our view step back from the highly confrontational and unpredictable policies of his predecessor in respect of foreign policy. Trump’s attempts to appeal to his domestic supporters through the threat and use of trade tariffs on foreign goods – and not just China but allies such as European nations and Canada – is likely to be seen as a policy failure in hindsight, delivering neither economic benefit nor polling advantages.

For these reasons, a Biden administration may have relatively little initial impact at the global market level but on a relative basis, investors may look towards other less highly valued markets to deliver returns. For example, we believe the long era of Europe’s consistent equity underperformance of the US could finally come to a close.

While Biden may choose to run a more conciliatory policy towards historic allies, the tensions between the US and China are likely to remain in place. The strategic questions in respect of a resurgent and clearly more assertive Chinese state span the US political divide and represent a national US issue. We do not think a Biden administration would stop the splintering of technology supply chains as firms seek to diversify suppliers to include those outside China for example. A political test of the new administration from China would also be a possibility during 2021.

US Election 2020: Promoting An Enduring Era Of US Influence

However, we believe a new US administration would be likely to aim for a lower profile set of China policies. A more carefully assessed long-term strategic objective of promoting an enduring era of US influence, stability and power on the international stage may result. Investors should welcome the absence of unnecessary uncertainty in this regard.

Unfortunately, the probability of a contested result cannot be excluded given the multiplicity of ways that a close result could be challenged in the US courts. There are for example procedural challenges that can be launched if it was believed that due process was not followed during the election and the battle lines in respect of mailed-in votes, which will account for a much larger share of the total than in previous years, have already been drawn by Trump’s campaign with lawyers standing by.

We believe Biden’s campaign is no less well legally-armed which means that a close contest will inevitably be challenged by either side which could lead to months of delay and more importantly the risk of policy paralysis at a critical time for the US economy. It is this result which we believe investors should be prepared for, even if they may be atypically indifferent to the success of either of the candidates.

Alistair George

Chief Investment Officer at Edison Group