Digital banks: Are fintechs a threat to traditional financial institutions?

When new launches of digital banks in the U.S. are plotted on the timeline below (2012-2019), it reveals a recent surge of activity. Banks are aware of these new entrants, yet seen on a single chart it highlights the sudden change.

Digital banks

“How did you go bankrupt?” – “Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly.” This quote by author Ernest Hemingway suggests that change is often slow, then sudden. Hemingway did not have the digital transformation of banking in mind, but the quote is apt.

Get The Full Seth Klarman Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Seth Klarman in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

Q3 2019 hedge fund letters, conferences and more

The time to market to launch a digital bank has shrunk significantly with SaaS solutions making it easier than for the first wave of Simple, Moven and Chime. Many of the newest banks are from fintechs that started in payment, lending or investing, and can quickly add a deposit account. These deposits are stickier and offer a loss leader for the fintech's more profitable service. Fintechs that began as point solutions that unbundled the bank (i.e., faster and cheaper cross-border payments like TransferWise) are now re-bundling into full-service bank alternatives.

digital banks

cegoh / Pixabay

Should banks ignore fintechs? For years, consultants and pundits (okay, me too) have been presenting slides showing fintechs offering better products and announcing the imminent demise of the bank, with comparisons to the lack of foresight at Borders and Blockbuster. Yet the banks are still around. Each wave of neo-banks has been met with skepticism by banking execs. First that they'd get licensed. They did. Then that they'd acquire customers. In only a few years, several fintechs already measure customers in the millions. Then that they could expand into new markets and products. The timeline above shows several fintechs operating in multiple regions. The latest skepticism is that the fintech business model is sustainable, and there is indeed a gap in data to refute this last doubt.

Disruption: Digital banks and fintechs

Forget how well funded fintechs are, valuations in the billions, or how many operate in a given category—all this suggests is the size of the bets being placed. Press releases citing impressive numbers of customers are irrelevant without context on the size of deposits and cost to serve.

The best documented is Monzo, though this level of transparency is exceptional. As public companies, the banks expose hard data on deposits and return on equity. By contrast, the neobanks are opaque private companies or line items within larger public companies, and it is impossible to ascertain whether their business is sustainable. Exceptions are established digital banks like Ally and USAA and public fintechs like PayPal, Square, and Intuit.

When I polled a room of banking executives last year, the biggest perceived threat had shifted from fintechs to digital giants for their ability to create value at scale. We now see T-Mobile and Uber on the timeline, but still no Google, Apple, Facebook, or Amazon. In a recent Gartner survey, 43% of FS CEO respondents did not accept the premise that these digital giants will be operating in their industry in the next five years. Five years is a long time and the change may be far more sudden.

Is it too late to adapt to the new entrants offering better digital banking services? Steering the battleship of a traditional bank can take years. Regardless of FS CEOs' lack of concern, accelerate your digital transformation rather than wait to see which digital giants are added in this timeline of bank launches for 2020.



About the Author

David Poole
David Poole is the Head of the Financial Services Center of Excellence at Publicis Sapient, the digital business transformation hub of Publicis Groupe. David consults on digital business transformation through innovation, thought leadership and customer insight with fifteen plus years of experience. David has been a speaker on the future of payments at industry events including Money 20/20, FIMA, NextBank, and CXFS. He is a change agent with 20+ years of experience as a researcher, and planner.