- September has historically been the weakest month for equities and one of the most volatile.
- Interest rate decisions from the Federal Reserve, Bank of Japan, and European Central Bank are all on tap this month.
- Washington, D.C. has to raise the debt ceiling and pass a budget or risk a potential government shutdown.
- Hedge Fund of funds Business Keeps Dying Every Year
- Baupost Letter Points To Concern Over Risk Parity, Systematic Strategies During Crisis
- AI Hedge Fund Robots Beating Their Human Masters
As the pace of life tends to pick up in September with kids back at school, the market is following suit with a month packed full of global events. The S&P 500 Index managed another gain in August, marking 10 consecutive months of gains on a total return basis. The global economy continues to improve and corporate earnings have been very strong across the globe, but how much longer can this calm continue? As we enter September, it is important to remember that no month has a worse average return for the S&P 500 (-1.0% going back to 1928*), and some of the most volatile moves ever have taken place this month. To help navigate the current environment, we’ve created this guide to the September 2017 market calendar, providing an overview of the key events.
At this year's SALT New York conference, Wences Casares, the chairman of XAPO, and Peter Briger, the principal and co-chief executive officer of Fortress Investment Group discussed the macro case for Bitcoin. Q2 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more XAPO describes itself as the first digital bank of its kind, which offers the "convenience" Read More
August Employment Report Review
Job growth disappointed in a quirky statistical month, but was still solid. The U.S. economy added 156,000 jobs in August, missing expectations of 180,000, and decelerating from a downwardly revised 189,000 in July. Jobs growth has historically been difficult to predict in August due to late summer transitions, and has had a tendency to be revised higher. This revision trend will be difficult to track as economic data in the coming months will likely display the impact of Hurricane Harvey, which made its initial landfall in the U.S. on August 25, 2017. Wage growth disappointed, rising only 0.1% month over month (2.5% year over year), after more solid growth of 0.3% last month (2.6% year over year), while the unemployment rate ticked up from 4.3% to 4.4%. Though the 2017 average of 186,000 jobs added per month is slower than the 2014–2016 average of 221,000, such slowdowns are normal as the economic cycle ages; even growth of 150,000 jobs per month would be enough to slowly tighten the labor market. The report may lower the likelihood of an additional Federal Reserve (Fed) rate hike in 2017.
One caveat to the report is that there was again weakness in the education component as there has been every August since 2011 due to shifts in the start of school years over time. As Figure 1 shows, the August jobs number has now come in beneath the initial estimate for seven consecutive years. The good news is that five of the previous six years it has been revised higher the next month—so we must stay tuned.
European Central Bank Meeting
The European Central Bank (ECB) has its next scheduled meeting on September 7, where it is expected to provide some clarity on quantitative easing (QE) policy. The current policy of purchasing 60 billion euro in bonds every month is slated to end this December. However, it is almost inconceivable that the ECB will completely stop buying bonds after this. The likely scenario is that it will continue to buy bonds with scheduled reductions in the monthly purchase in a process called “tapering.” One reason to taper purchases is that they are literally running out of bonds to buy. The ECB has set limits for itself regarding how much of any one country’s bonds it can purchase and at what interest rates it will buy them, and these criteria have made it difficult to find available bonds.
While we think the ECB will taper purchases, it is unlikely to announce a definitive end to QE. Inflation has been stubbornly low in Europe and boosting inflation to 2% is one of the ECB’s stated goals. Politically speaking, it would be very difficult for the ECB to have to restart its QE policy should it stop buying bonds altogether. Though regardless of the details of their announcement, the ECB is a long way from beginning to normalize policy, at least until 2019 or more likely 2020.
The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the Fed’s policymaking arm, will hold its sixth of eight meetings this year on September 19–20. At 2 p.m. ET on September 20, the FOMC will release its policy statement, a new set of members’ forecasts on the economy, labor market, and inflation, and a new set of “dot plots” (members’ forecasts of where they think the fed funds rate will be at the end of 2017, 2018, 2019, and in the “long run”). Fed Chair Janet Yellen will also hold the third post-FOMC meeting press conference of the year at 2:30 p.m. ET on September 20.
As of Friday, September 1, 2017, the market, as measured by fed funds futures, is pricing in just a 1% chance of a 25 basis point (0.25%) rate hike at the meeting, and a 42% chance of a hike in December. However, there will be additional information for markets to digest between now and mid-September—including consumer and producer inflation (inflation is a key factor for the Fed’s rate hike trajectory), the Institute for Supply Management’s (ISM) Non-Manufacturing Index, and retail sales—which could change the odds of future rate hikes.
Though markets aren’t expecting a rate hike in September, some market participants are expecting the Fed to announce the beginning of its balance sheet normalization plan. The minutes of the Fed’s July meeting showed continued discussion of starting to allow maturing bonds to roll off the Fed’s balance sheet at a measured pace, and though the Fed hasn’t given an exact timeframe for an announcement yet, the July meeting statement did say it intended to begin implementing the program “relatively soon.” Given that there will not be another meeting with a press conference until December, these comments likely point to a September announcement, assuming no unexpected economic or market disruptions occur between now and then.
Bank Of Japan Meeting
The Bank of Japan (BOJ), unlike the ECB, is likely to continue its current policy of aggressively buying assets at its September 21 meeting. Even though Japan’s economy has begun to accelerate, the BOJ continues to push back its forecast of when Japan will reach its 2% inflation target, with the latest estimate in early 2020. Little change is expected in the current policy of buying 170 billion yen (roughly $150 billion) per year in Japanese government and corporate bonds, real estate investment trusts, and stocks, for the foreseeable future.
Debt Ceiling Expires And Potential Government Shutdown
In theory, on September 29, the U.S. government will exceed its ability to borrow additional money to fund services, as well as pay interest on existing debt. However, the exact date is unknown, and there are short-term fixes that the Treasury Department could use to raise enough funds to potentially last a few more weeks. While failure to raise the debt ceiling could lead to a technical default on our bonds, with unknown political and economic ramifications, we view it as highly unlikely that Congress would allow this occur. One possibility to ensure its passage of an increase would be to tie it to another “must pass” bill, like providing relief to the victims of Hurricane Harvey.
Though a second more benign threat also looms. The government’s fiscal year ends on September 30, and if it does not pass a budget there will be no money to fund operations, resulting in a government shutdown. The most recent and probably most impactful shutdown was in October 2013, when the government was closed for 16 days. The economic impact of the shutdown was estimated to be about $24 billion in lost gross domestic product (GDP), or about 0.15% of total GDP that year. The S&P 500 gained 2.4% during the shutdown. But the potential political impact is more subjective. At the time, most Americans (8 out of 10) said that the shutdown was a bad idea. However, today more Americans seem to think that a shutdown would be beneficial to change what they perceive to be a “business as usual” culture in Washington, D.C.
Ultimately, Congress is going to have to pass a budget. But more recently Congress has been using continuing resolutions (CR) to provide temporary funding to keep the government going until a full budget is passed. In addition to creating future potential flash points that could result in a shutdown, using a CR delays the impact of budgetary policy and extends uncertainty about what that policy will even be. Furthermore, the longer Congress deals with mandatory budget issues, the less time they have for other issues, such as corporate tax reform.
September has several important events that markets will be watching closely, which only increases the chances of overall market volatility. From three major central bank decisions, to Congress coming back to work and confronting some important deadlines, the stage is set for a few fireworks. Markets may be able to discount some of the noise, but if you factor in that the month tends to be volatile regardless, September 2017 may certainly be a month to watch.
Article by LPL Financial