Low-Performing PE Firms Still Holding Their Own vs. Public Markets

Low-Performing PE Firms

Is private equity performance consistent? Managers will tell you yes—according to marketing materials, nearly every manager boasts of top-quartile performance. But squishy numbers and contestable metrics have clouded the industry for years, and investors apparently fall for them every cycle.

Get our full guide on moat investing in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on moat investing in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

Also read:

While PE fund performance obviously varies, PitchBook’s analyst team wanted to see if the firms themselves performed consistently over time. After assigning quartiles to 1,300 individual funds across 310 PE firms, we averaged out and collated the fund quartiles (organized by vintage) into a firm ranking, graphed below. As we argue in a recent research note, there is a pronounced discrepancy between top performing firms and bottom performers: For first- and fourth-quartile firms, roughly half of the funds were consistent with firm ranking.

This isn’t news, per se. Several academic studies also reach this conclusion but often find top-quartile PE firm performance, net of fees, to be roughly equal to their public market equivalents. In other words, even the best GPs don’t outperform stocks and bonds when their PE funds are bundled together. Our research note found the opposite: Top-performing firms outpaced the Russell 3000 at every horizon, but especially at the 10- and 15-year marks (1.35x and 1.42x, respectively). What’s more, even bottom-performing firms held their own, notching a 1.06x multiple against the PME at the one- and 15-year horizons. That helps explain one head-scratching trend: 41% of consistently bottom-quartile firms managed to raise at least three follow-on funds, and another 9% raised five or more.

We might joke about all the “top-quartile” teams running around asking for more money, but even the poor performers have a few numbers on their side.

Note: This column was previously published in The Lead Left.

You can read the full analyst note here.

Article by Alex Lykken, PitchBook

For exclusive info on hedge funds and the latest news from value investing world at only a few dollars a month check out ValueWalk Premium right here.

Multiple people interested? Check out our new corporate plan right here (We are currently offering a major discount)






Be the first to comment on "Low-Performing PE Firms Still Holding Their Own vs. Public Markets"

Leave a comment