China A-shares could shortly be included in a key international benchmark for the first time—in a way that highlights smarter efforts by the West to help China integrate fully into global markets.
Each year since 2014, index provider MSCI has consulted with equity-market practitioners on whether the time has been right to admit China A-shares, traded on onshore markets, into the MSCI Emerging Market Index. To date, the answer has been “no”—but we believe that this year the answer will be “yes.”
The reason: MSCI has dropped its usual rigorously applied standard terms of entry in favor of a more gradualist and pragmatic approach. The move will involve fewer stocks initially, sourced under simpler institutional arrangements than those offered in previous proposals.
Mohnish Pabrai Returns 10.1% In 2020, Changes Strategy [2020 Letter]
Mohnish Pabrai's flagship hedge fund, the Pabrai Investment Fund II, returned 29.6% in the second half of 2020. Following this performance, the fund returned 10.1% net for the year, underperforming the S&P 500 but outperforming the Dow Jones Industrial Average, which returned just 9.7%. According to a copy of the investment manager's year-end letter to Read More
This is an exciting development, for two reasons. First, even a modest initial inclusion in the index will be a significant step forward in bringing China—which has an equity-market capitalization of US$7.5 trillion—fully into global capital markets.
Second, it suggests that Western companies have taken a leaf out of China’s own book on how to approach the huge challenge of modernizing the country’s capital markets.
If at First You Don’t Succeed…
There are three ways for foreign investors to participate in China A-shares. Two are licensing regimes while the third consists of arm’s length trading arrangements on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges.
The Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor (QFII) scheme and the RMB Qualified Foreign Institutional Investor (RQFII) scheme, introduced in 2002 and 2011 respectively, allow direct access to China’s capital markets. Investors are subject to conditions including licensing requirements, quotas and redemption limitations.
Since 2014 and last December respectively, the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges have participated in Stock Connect. This program links them to the Hong Kong Stock Exchange and enables foreign investors to buy A-shares with fewer restrictions than under the QFII schemes.
Until this year, MSCI’s proposals to include A-shares in its index were based on the QFII/RQFII framework and 448 stocks. The terms and conditions of the QFII licensing regime, however, were among the obstacles to the market’s acceptance of the proposals.
…Try a Fresh Approach
MSCI appears to have learned from this. Just as China did when pausing for nine years between the launch of QFII and RQFII, and two years between adding the Shanghai and Shenzhen exchanges to Stock Connect, MSCI is taking a “softly, softly” approach.
This year, MSCI is proposing to include in the index only A-shares sourced under the Stock Connect regime. This narrows the universe of investible stocks but, as Stock Connect is not subject to the same restrictions governing QFII, the proposal, in our view, has a real chance of being accepted.
Initially, the 169 stocks envisaged under this proposal would increase China’s presence in the Emerging Market Index by just 50 basis points, to 28.6%. But that’s the thin end of the wedge.
When the 169 stocks go into the index (which we expect will happen in June 2018), they will do so at a low initial inclusion factor. The next step will be for MSCI to increase the weightings.
This will immediately take the A-shares’ portion of the index from 50 basis points to 8.6%. But it doesn’t stop there. Currently, the total number of shares included in the Stock Connect scheme is 1,479 compared with more than 2,900 available under the QFII system.
As Stock Connect grows over time and A-shares become fully included in the index, China’s overall weighting is likely to grow to nearly 40% (Display).
Its share of the MSCI All Country World Index would increase from 3% to 4%, raising it from joint sixth place currently to fourth place behind the US, Japan and the UK (and ahead of France, Canada and Germany).
Impact on Global Equity Allocations
For some investors, China’s policy risks and economic challenges over the last few years have cast a shadow over the country’s huge potential. To quote Napoleon Bonaparte, however: “China is a sleeping giant. Let her sleep, for when she wakes she will move the world.”
We think that assessment is still relevant. And the entry of China A-shares into the Emerging Market Index sooner rather than later will remind investors that the giant, when it wakes, will have a meaningful impact on their global equity allocations.
The best way to prepare for this, in our view, is to follow China and MSCI and take the long view. That means looking beyond China’s present uncertainties and preparing steadily and purposefully for its rise to even greater prominence in world markets.
The views expressed herein do not constitute research, investment advice or trade recommendations and do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio-management teams.
Article by John Lin, Alliance Bernstein