I have owned shares of the largest Canadian Banks as a long-term investment for over four years now. I initiated a position in those five banks in early 2013, and then added some more in late 2013. I also added a little more a couple of years later. If prices make sense, and I have money to invest, I will likely make another investment. The banks include:
Bank of Montreal (BMO) provides various retail banking, wealth management, and investment banking products and services in North America and internationally. It has operations in the US, in the form of BMO Harris Bank. Bank of Montreal has paid dividends since 1829. Over the past decade, Bank of Montreal has increased quarterly dividends per share by 3.10%/year. And that’s despite the fact that the dividends were as left unchanged in 2009, 2010 and 2011. Earnings per share have increased by 3%/year over the same time period. The bank sells for 14.90 times earnings and yields 3.40%.
The Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS) provides various personal, commercial, corporate, and investment banking services in Canada and internationally. It operates in four segments: Canadian Banking, International Banking, Global Wealth & Insurance, and Global Banking & Markets. This is the most international Canadian bank, as it has services in Caribbean, Latin America, Central America, and Asia. Bank of Nova Scotia has paid dividends since 1834. Over the past decade, Bank of Nova Scotia has increased its quarterly dividends per share by 5.80%/year. And that’s despite the fact that the annual dividend was left unchanged in 2010. Earnings per share have increased by 5%/year over the same time period. The bank sells for 13.70 times earnings and yields 3.75%.
Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CM) provides various financial products and services to individuals, small businesses, and commercial, corporate, and institutional clients in Canada and internationally. The company operates through three segments: Retail and Business Banking, Wealth Management, and Wholesale Banking. Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce has paid dividends since 1890. Over the past decade, Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce has increased its quarterly dividends per share by 5.90%/year. And that’s despite the fact that the annual dividend was left unchanged in 2009 and 2010. Earnings per share have increased by 3.70%/year over the same time period. The bank sells for 11.20 times earnings and yields 4.15%.
Royal Bank of Canada (RY), a diversified financial service company, provides personal and commercial banking, wealth management, insurance, investor, and capital markets products and services worldwide. This is another bank that has operations in the US. Royal Bank of Canada has paid dividends since 1870. Over the past decade, Royal Bank of Canada has increased dividends per share by 7.60%/year. And that’s despite the fact that the annual dividend was left unchanged in 2009 and 2010. Earnings per share have increased by 6.60%/year over the same time period. The bank sells for 14.40 times earnings and yields 3.40%.
The Toronto-Dominion Bank, (TD) provides financial and banking services in North America and internationally. The company also has significant operations in the US. The Toronto-Dominion Bank has paid dividends since 1857. Over the past decade, The Toronto-Dominion Bank has increased its quarterly dividends per share at a rate of 8.60%/year. And that’s despite the fact that the annual dividend was left unchanged in 2010. Earnings per share have increased by 4%/year over the same time period. The bank sells for 14.10 times earnings and yields 3.30%.
All of those banks can easily be purchased by US investors in their regular taxable or tax-deferred accounts. There is a sixth Canadian bank, called National Bank of Canada (NTIOF), which is a little bit more difficult to purchase for US investors because it is traded on the pink sheets and not on the major exchanges. Because of low liquidity, and because some brokers do not allow access to that, it may not be available for everyone.
Overall, I like the fact that Canadian Banks didn’t cut or eliminate dividends during the 2007 – 2009 financial crisis. Instead, they kept them steady for a few years, and have been increasing them for a few years now as well. I don’t believe this was due to dumb luck, but because there were stricter lending practices, than what we had in the US prior to the Great Recession.
In the grand scheme of things, I am bullish on Canada in the very long-term. An investment in all banks is a bet that Canada will be a developed country in 30 – 40 – 50 years (after that – I don’t care from a personal perspective). It is a bet that its economy will gradually grow over time, the number of people will increase, and that Canadian people and businesses will need the services of a financial institution. I think that the Canadian government has its house in order, and that the relatively more open immigration system will encourage faster population growth.
It seems that most of the banking in Canada is done through one of those five largest banks. There are a few smaller ones, but I chose to only focus on the larger entities. Once a consumer starts using the services of one of the banks, they get used to it, and the switching costs are high. Once you establish that relationship with the bank and a banker, chances are that you will do checking through it, manage your investments, use credit cards and take on loans like car or mortgage on a house. Therefore, I believe they have competitive advantages, and scale of operations.
That being said, I have no idea whether there will be a financial crisis in Canada in the next 5 – 10 years. It is possible that one of the largest five banks fails during the next major recession. That’s fine, because the ones left standing will pick up the business and do better. This is why I am putting equal amounts of investment in each bank. No matter how the economy does, banking needs to get done, meaning that one of those five banks will get business. Again, as a long-term investor, my holding period is in the decades. I know growth is not going to be smooth year over year, which is why I am fine with encountering bumps along the road. This will help me build out my positions at cheaper prices.
Canada’s economy is dependent on volatile commodity prices, which are some the country’s chief exports. It is is exposed to the cyclical commodity prices such as oil and natural gas. Therefore, its banks will be more affected by drops in commodity prices than Wells Fargo (WFC) in the US. In addition, the Canadian dollar is also closely correlated with the rise and fall of commodity prices. For a US investor, this means that the level of dividend income in US dollars from their Canadian dividend portfolio may be a little volatile, even if it rises over time in the base currency. I do believe it makes sense however to evaluate the fundamental performance of an international dividend company in base currency, rather