Why Tesla Motors Inc (TSLA) May Have The Keys To The Electric Vehicle Market by [email protected]
Wharton’s John Paul MacDuffie and Stanford’s Wesley R. Hartmann discuss Tesla’s Model 3.
“The Week that Electric Vehicles Went Mainstream,” is how Tesla Motors headlined its blog post last week, citing more than 325,000 pre-bookings for the Model 3 electric car it launched on March 31. “[That] corresponds to about $14 billion in implied future sales, making this the single biggest one-week launch of any product ever,” the company boasted. Deliveries are set to begin in 2017.
Tesla may well be on the way to mainstreaming the electric vehicle market for itself and its competitors. In addition to the wide appeal the Model 3 seems to command, several other aspects point to a potential journey away from a niche market for Tesla. The car’s $35,000 price tag is half the price of the Model S ($75,000) and the Model X ($80,000). Bookings for the Model 3 have surprised even Tesla’s founder and CEO Elon Musk, coming at a time when gasoline prices are low.
“Electric vehicles increasingly are being seen not necessarily as green or as a way to save on fuel costs, but as incredibly powerful, with amazing acceleration, and fun to drive,” said Wharton management professor John Paul MacDuffie, an automobile industry expert. In fact, he noted that the organizers of the Formula One auto races (Fédération Internationale de l’Automobile, or FIA) have launched a separate series for electric vehicles called the Formula E. Even the Formula One cars are all hybrids, combining the high acceleration of electric vehicles with traditional engines, he noted.
Wesley R. Hartmann, marketing professor of management at Stanford University, said the Model 3 “is the make or break for whether the electric vehicle market will take off and whether Tesla will be a critical part of it, as opposed to being a niche player.”
MacDuffie and Hartmann discussed Tesla’s Model 3 and the challenges the firm faces in tapping the mainstream market on the [email protected] show on Wharton Business Radio on SiriusXM channel 111. (Listen to the podcast at the top of this page.)
Kudos Flow In
MacDuffie said it was “telling” that Carlos Ghosn, chairman and CEO of Nissan of Japan and Renault of France, has welcomed the Model 3 bookings, “because it suggests a growing and enthusiastic market for these vehicles.”
MacDuffie also noted that bookings have been strong despite low gas prices, indicating that gas prices are not the primary driver of demand for electric vehicles. “People buying a $70,000 to $110,000 car aren’t worried about what they pay out at the gas pump,” he said. “If the demand exists even with gas prices being low, it is [because] of that repositioning away from just an environmental pitch.”
Hartmann said the enthusiasm for the Model 3 “speaks to what Tesla has been able to communicate to the market in terms of the products they can develop and how much people would want those.” He likened it to “people lining up to get” the latest Apple iPhones.
“Electric vehicles increasingly are being seen not necessarily as green or as a way to save on fuel costs, but as incredibly powerful [and] fun to drive.”–John Paul MacDuffie
MacDuffie put the pre-bookings for the Model 3 in perspective. The $1,000 down payment that Tesla requires is not an order commitment and is a refundable deposit, he noted. “But it is an extraordinary interest-free loan to Tesla to get in the queue and to have the bragging rights of being early to get a hot product,” he said.
Braving New Competition
If other automakers are keenly watching the progress of the Model 3, they would want to jump in, too. “What if competitor products are available earlier and they are good [and] well-priced?” asked MacDuffie. That could affect Tesla’s bottom line, he noted, but “if it’s a growing market, there should be room for everybody.”
Wharton marketing professor Americus Reed is optimistic for Tesla. “Tesla will be fine because it is a strong brand that is positioned as and is seen as very different from the other car manufacturers’ attempts at creating an electric car,” he said.
Reed added that Musk’s own brand image has also helped build a moat around Tesla. “Part of [Tesla’s] brand is a clear futurist visionary who himself is changing the world,” Reed noted, referring to Musk’s other roles as the founder of space transportation company SpaceX and co-founder of solar power company SolarCity.
“[Musk] is this larger-than-life character who makes you think of — in the computer industry — Steve Jobs, but [also] in the early auto industry history someone like Henry Ford,” said MacDuffie. “[Their] charisma and the boldness of their vision had an influence on people.”
Even so, questions persist about whether Tesla can pull it off, MacDuffie added. “The big question is: Can they really scale it up? What will the model look like when [the Model 3] hits the market at that price point? Will the price stay put or edge up?”
MacDuffie noted that Tesla has been a niche, low-volume producer, and the Model 3 would put it much more into the mass-market, mass-production range. “They haven’t done that before,” he said. “But they have learned to do other stuff that they didn’t know how to do, and so it would be risky to bet against them.”
The Model 3 “is the make or break for whether the electric vehicle market will take off and whether Tesla will be a critical part of it, as opposed to being a niche player.”–Wesley R. Hartmann
The Model 3 would also benefit from the luxury brand image of Tesla’s earlier models. MacDuffie noted that most automakers have historically started with inexpensive vehicles as they established their reputations, manufacturing capabilities, supply chains and dealer networks. They moved up-market at a later stage, sometimes by introducing new brands — as with the Lexus from Toyota, he explained. “Tesla did it exactly the opposite way; it established itself at the luxury end,” he said. “Obviously, it will benefit from the way in which that luxury brand cachet will rub off on the Model 3.”
MacDuffie noted that Musk has attributed to “hubris” his decision to move from the original Model S to a more expensive car with the Model X ($80,000 and upwards). “That suggests a willingness to learn from a mistake,” he said. “In a way, designing a lower cost car is a big design and engineering challenge.”
Rather than Tesla’s luxury brand cachet rubbing off on the Model 3, “the more interesting question is the reverse,” said Reed. “What will happen to the brand as a unique luxury high end vehicle if suddenly it is ubiquitous in the mass market? What will a high-wealth individual who paid $70,000 or more think when he sees these $35,000 versions?”
Hartmann said that with the