Business

Estimating The Value Of Steve Jobs Using An Event Study

Estimating The Value Of Steve Jobs Using An Event Study

Pornsit Jiraporn

Pennsylvania State University – School of Graduate Professional Studies (SGPS)

Napatsorn Jiraporn

State University of New York at New Paltz

Pattanaporn Kitsabunnarat-Chatjuthamard

Sasin GIBA

Shenghui Tong

Central University of Finance and Economics (CUFE)

February 23, 2016

Abstract:

Using an event study approach, we seek to estimate the value investors placed on Steve Jobs by investigating the stock market reactions to his death. In the three-day window surrounding his death, the estimated cumulative abnormal returns (CAR) are -5.76%. Given the market capitalization of Apple at the time, it can be inferred that investors valued Steve Jobs at 20 billion dollars. While tragic, the news about Jobs’ death is greeted favorably by Apple’s competitors. The competitors appear to be convinced that, without Steve Jobs, they can compete with Apple better.

Estimating The Value Of Steve Jobs Using An Event Study – Introduction

Apple has returned to the spotlight once again with the announcement that its profit in the fourth quarter of 2014 is 18 billion, the largest profit ever reported by a corporation. As of 2014, Apple is also the largest company by market capitalization, which is nearly 700 billion dollars. Because Apple was founded by Steve Jobs, his name is always linked to the company. Steve Jobs was regarded as a successful entrepreneur and inventor, a visionary that does not come along very often. He was chairman and CEO of Apple Inc. and played an important part in the development of the iPhone, iMac, iPod, and iPad. Apple went from a near bankruptcy to the world’s most valuable publicly traded company in 2011. It is obvious that his ideas and inventions have had a profound impact on the way we live. Although it is not possible to quantify the impact of his inventions on the society at large, we seek to quantify how much value investors placed on Steve Jobs by investigating the market reactions to his death. Steve Jobs passed away on October 5, 2011 around 3 PM, due to insulinoma or cancer of the pancreas. He was 56.

Prior research has examined the stock market reactions of the deaths of firm executives. For instance, Johnson, Magee, Nagarajan, and Newman (1985) investigate the market reactions to unexpected deaths of senior executives. More recently, Nguyen and Nielsen (2010), in an attempt to assess the value of independent directors, examine the stock price reactions of sudden deaths of independent directors. They find that the firm’s stock price drops by almost one percent, implying that independent directors are beneficial to firm value. Nguyen and Nielsen (2014) measure the value of top executives by using the stock price reactions of their sudden deaths. The results show that managers with higher perceived contributions to shareholder value obtain higher pay.

Using the standard event study methodology, our analysis shows that, in the three-day period surrounding Steve Jobs’ death, the estimated cumulative abnormal returns (CAR) are – 5.76%, a highly statistically significant drop. Given the market capitalization of Apple at the time, which was $350 billion, shareholders lost 20.16 billion dollars in the three-day period, a substantial wealth loss in such a short period of time. It appears that investors placed a substantial value on Steve Jobs. This is quite remarkable because he was no longer the CEO of Apple at the time of his death. He had earlier stepped down and passed on the baton to Tim Cook. It was also public knowledge that he had been battling cancer for years. So, his death was probably anticipated to some extent by investors. In spite of such anticipation, his death still brought about large negative stock market reactions.

Sample selection and Methodology

We collect data on stock returns from the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). We identify firms in the same industry as Apple by using the first two digits of the Standard Industrial Classification Code (SIC). Firm characteristics are obtained from COMPUSTAT. To examine the stock price reactions, we employ the standard event study approach. We use a 255-day estimation period, from day -300 to day -46. We define Day 0 as October 5, 2011, the day Steve Jobs passed away. We use market-adjusted returns and a value-weighted market index in our calculations. The results are qualitatively similar when different variants of the event study approach are employed.

Results

a. Stock market reactions to Steve Jobs’ death

Ex-ante, it is not obvious how the stock market should react to his death. On the one hand, it can be argued that his departure represents a significant loss to Apple and thus the stock market reactions should be significantly negative. On the contrary, it was well-known that he had been ill, having battled cancer for several years. He also discussed his declining health and resigned as Apple CEO a few months before his death. He did say much earlier that he would remain the CEO until his health condition did not allow him to do so. Thus, the fact that he left the CEO position strongly suggested that his health condition probably deteriorated. This information was likely incorporated into the stock price prior to his death. His death was probably anticipated to some extent by some investors. Furthermore, at the time of his death, Tim Cook was in full control of the company. Jobs had not been involved in the company for a few months. The stock price should have already reflected the value of Apple with Tim Cook in full control. If this is the case, then the market reactions may not be significant.

Steve Jobs

Steve Jobs

See full PDF below.