And this is the graph of CONSOL, an energy company that has gone from $40 to $7. Again, we timed it poorly, initially buying in the 30s and adding all the way down.
Get The Full Seth Klarman Series in PDF
Get the entire 10-part series on Seth Klarman in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.
Source: Bloomberg LP as of November 13,2015.CONSOL is at $7.40 a share, giving it a $1.7 billion market cap, and a $5.5 billion enterprise value.
Source:CNXfilingsavailableathttp://phx.corporate?ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=66439&p=irol?sec;BloombergLP pricing as of November 13, 2015; and Greenlight calculations. Minority interest is based on the publically tradedvalueofCNX CoalResourcesLP(CNXC) notownedbyCNX asofNovember2015.The market views CONSOL as a coal company. We disagree, but let's look at it through that lens for a moment.
[drizzle]These are coal stocks, and among them CONSOL is not an outlier.
As you can see, the whole industry has practically been left for dead. Even CONSOL’s bonds trade like it might go out of business.
Source:GreenlightcalculationsbasedonpricingdatafromBloombergLPasofNovember13,2015. ComparativecoalcompaniesselectedinthesolediscretionofGreenlight.A decade ago, coal was used to generate roughly half of all electricity in the U.S.
Source:GreenlightcalculationsusingU.S.EnergyInformationAdministration(“EIA”)monthlyU.S.electricity generation data, filtered on the electric power sector, retrieved November 2015, from EIA’s custom table builderatwww.eia.gov/forecasts/steo/query.ClassificationsselectedinthesolediscretionofGreenlight.Thanks to the shale gas revolution and environmental regulations, coal is no longer king. We burn less of it and its price has declined.
Source:Source:PlattsCoal,obtainedNovember2015.While coal used to provide nearly half of U.S. electricity, it’s now providing less than 35%.
Source:GreenlightcalculationsusingEIAmonthlyU.S.electricitygenerationdata,filteredontheelectric power sector, retrieved November 2015, from EIA’s custom table builder at www.eia.gov/forecasts/steo/query.Figuresfor2015areyeartodatethroughSeptember30,3015.ClassificationsselectedinthesolediscretionofGreenlight.We’ve gone from producing more than a billion tons of thermal coal annually to less than 850 million tons in the last five years, and everyone agrees that this trend will continue.
Source: Greenlight calculations using EIA annual U.S. coal supply, consumption, and inventories data, retrievedNovember2015,fromEIA’sshorttermenergyoutlookbrowser(beta)atwww.eia.gov/beta/steo/. Thermalcoalistotalcoallessexportedmetallurgicalcoalandcokeplantconsumption...................
n case you can't read that cartoon, it says, "I suspect my husband's hiking on me.“We’re going to focus on the coal coming out of Appalachia, an area known for being a favorite hiking spot of South Carolina governors.
Appalachia has been hit especially hard by the falling demand.
In the past few years we’ve seen at least 20 coal companies go into bankruptcy, liquidating their inventories into an already oversupplied market as they do so.
The current spot price is just $43 per ton, down from about $80 four years ago.