Primatologists Erupt In Debate Over Chimpanzees Accent Study

reminiscences of a stock operator pdf

The controversial study claimed that chimpanzees adapt their grunts to facilitate communication with new neighbors.

Three researchers have now written to the journal Current Biology suggesting that there may be something wrong with the results, which were taken from a group of chimps who moved from a safari park in the Netherlands to Edinburgh Zoo, Scotland, according to the BBC.

Chimpanzees study criticized by other primatologists

“There are a number of problems with the original study,” said Dr James Higham, from New York University. “Some of these relate to the methods used, while others are fundamentally a misrepresentation of what the data actually show.”

The scientists behind the original study have spoken out in defense of their work. Dr Simon Townsend of Warwick University, who co-wrote the original study with colleagues in York and St Andrews, told the BBC: “We think that we’ve addressed the points that they bring up. It’s an interesting critique of our research – and this is exactly how science works.”

The work related to a change in the call for apples used by the chimps. Over time the chimps apparently changed the call to match that used by their new neighbors, and it became lower-pitched and less enthusiastic despite the fact that they continued to enjoy eating apples.

Debate rumbles on between different camps

Now scientists are questioning whether the calls were ever very different. They have re-plotted the data collected by the original team and emphasized the similarities between the calls used by both groups of chimps, showing how scientists can draw distinct conclusions from the same set of data.

Even if they accept that the calls did change, the critics argue that it is due to a change in accent rather than learning a new call. One critic, Dr Higham, told the BBC that it was necessary to discuss the research because it was “widely publicized (and over-interpreted),” and said that there was no intention of “trying to tear down other people’s research”.

“There are some genuine and very strong disagreements among primate communication researchers about what these types of data show, and mean,” he said in an email.

Although it seems likely that the debate will rumble on for the foreseeable future, Dr. Townsend also believes it is a “useful exchange” that could prove valuable to others in the field.

For exclusive info on hedge funds and the latest news from value investing world at only a few dollars a month check out ValueWalk Premium right here.

Multiple people interested? Check out our new corporate plan right here (We are currently offering a major discount)



About the Author

Brendan Byrne
While studying economics, Brendan found himself comfortably falling down the rabbit hole of restaurant work, ultimately opening a consulting business and working as a private wine buyer. On a whim, he moved to China, and in his first week following a triumphant pub quiz victory, he found himself bleeding on the floor based on his arrogance. The same man who put him there offered him a job lecturing for the University of Wales in various sister universities throughout the Middle Kingdom. While primarily lecturing in descriptive and comparative statistics, Brendan simultaneously earned an Msc in Banking and International Finance from the University of Wales-Bangor. He's presently doing something he hates, respecting French people. Well, two, his wife and her mother in the lovely town of Antigua, Guatemala. To contact Brendan or give him an exclusive, please contact him at theflask@gmail.com

Be the first to comment on "Primatologists Erupt In Debate Over Chimpanzees Accent Study"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.