ValueX Vail 2015 – Group 1 Automotive: Driving Value In An Inflated Market

ValueX Vail 2015 – Group 1 Automotive: Driving Value In An Inflated Market

Moon Capital Management’s presentation on Group 1 Automotive Driving Value in an Inflated Market from the ValueX Vail, June 24, 2015.

Group 1 Automotive

  • Group 1 owns and operates auto dealerships
    • Third largest dealership group in the U.S. retailing 275,000 new and used vehicles annually
    • 104 US dealerships, 17 UK dealerships, 17 Brazil dealerships
    • Market capitalization of $2.0 billion
  • Recent valuation multiples
    • ’15e P/E: 11.5x

Local Monopolies

  • Dealers provided a great deal of protection in different states (receive long-term operating agreements because they are independently owned and capitalized)
  • Franchise agreements provide geographic exclusivity in densely populated areas
  • Law requires that the sales channel for new cars must be directed through the dealer network
  • Manufacture paid maintenance service required to be completed at dealership
  • Expensive OEM specific tools and diagnostics provide barriers to entry for service techs at independent shops

Economic Moat

Get The Full Seth Klarman Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Seth Klarman in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues.

Deceptively High-Quality Business

  • Inventory is financed through vehicle floorplan notes payable from various OEMs
    • Notes accrue like other types of borrowing, but OEMs extend “floorplan assistance” to offset the expense
    • Little inventory risk as the OEMs provide retailers with significant incentives to move inventory and dealers are often paid to carry
  • Dealership decline has improved the competitive environment
    • Dealers down 20% over the past seven years
    • GM allowed to rationalize its dealer network during bankruptcy (cut network by 30%)

Strong National Footprint

Group 1 Automotive

Peter Lynch: How Investors Can Find Their Edge

Peter LynchPeter Lynch was one of the best growth investors of all time. As the Magellan Fund manager at Fidelity Investments between 1977 and 1990, he averaged a 29.2% annual return. Q1 2021 hedge fund letters, conferences and more The fund manager's investment strategy was straightforward. He wanted to find growth companies and sit on them Read More

Business Mix

  • New Vehicle- 54% of sales, 20% of gross profit
    • Roughly $1,850 in gross profit per vehicle, with certain luxury vehicles bringing in more than twice this amount.
    • These per car margins are lower than historical norms
  • Used Vehicle- 30% of sales, 13% of gross profit
    • Roughly $1,600 in gross profit per vehicle
    • Unwanted cars sold at breakeven into the wholesale market
  • Finance & Insurance- 4% of sales, 26% of gross profit
    • Fees and spreads on car loans and leases
    • Purely a fee-based earnings stream for arranging third-party financing, insurance, etc.
  • Parts & Service- 12% of sales, 41% of gross profit
    • The real profit center of the dealership

Finance & Insurance

  • Pure margin business– Group 1 Automotive receives roughly $1,350 per unit for arranging financing, service, and insurance contracts
    • Financing: 1/3 of F&I ($450) comes in the form of flat fees or financing spreads paid to arrange a loan
    • Vehicle Warranty and Protection: 2/3 of F&I comes from fees earned from selling third-party extended warranty, vehicle service, and insurance products


Group 1 Automotive

CFPB - Headline Risk

ValueX Vail 2015 - Group 1 Automotive: Driving Value In An Inflated Market

  • The CFPB’s intent is to monitor discrimination practices not set pricing—the CFPB agrees that dealers should be compensated for processing financing
  • Any impact is limited to financing—dealer markups represent 1/3 or less of F&I income
  • The expectation is that lenders will be forced to move from dealer reserves (interest rate markups) to flat fees
  • Certain lenders including BMO Harris Bank in Chicago have moved to flat fees (3% of finance amount) with no change of consequence to dealer economics
  • Dealer economics are unlikely to change as they will continue to choose which lenders get the financing business

Parts & Service (The Real Profit Driver)

Group 1 Automotive

  • Gross margins run at 52% (half is service at 70-80% margin, half is parts at 35% margin)
  • Trends in manufacture-paid maintenance have improved economics for dealers—since service is free to customers, the dealer retains the entire service stream
  • Customers may look outside hometown for a new car purchase, but they are a captive customer for car servicing
  • Price & Servicing is driven by the servicing base (0-5 year fleet)

Near-Term Catalysts: SAAR Rebound

Group 1 Automotive

See full presentation below.

No posts to display