In the run-up to the much heralded Alibaba IPO, IG has been offering a grey market on the anticipated value of the e-commerce giant at the close of the first day of trading. This Q & A briefing assesses the IG grey market and prospects for the IPO from IG.com.
Find out more about the launch price of recent IPOs such as Twitter Inc (NYSE:TWTR), Royal Mail PLC (LON:RMG) and TSB Banking Group PLC (LON:TSB):
How has IG’s grey market for the Alibaba IPO performed since its launch in March?
IG: There was some early volatility, up as high as $260 and down to $175 billion. For the past three months our grey market has been trading fairly tightly between $195-205 billion, that is, until the early part of September where it is now at $202-212 billion which suggests both an increase in interest and activity.
What can we say about the performance trend?
IG: The initial wide range of trading reflects the breadth of opinion on the possible size of the IPO, reflecting the degree of uncertainty surrounding Alibaba as a business. After levelling out around the $198 billion mark it appeared that traders had found a comfort level. Its subsequent move upward to $202-212 billion suggests that the recent flurry of media speculation surrounding the IPO date has increased investor appetite for IG’s grey market.
How does the IG valuation compare with the initial estimates?
IG: Our grey market peaked at the top side of the initial estimate of Alibaba’s value, but hasn’t yet looked like going near its lowest extreme. The current level of $202-212 billion firmly places Alibaba in the top half of its initial range, trading at around 54 times its earnings.
Are there any other headline observations to be made about the Alibaba grey market?
IG: At its current value of $202-212 billion, the IG grey market for Alibaba is substantially greater than Facebook’s highly impressive $105 billion IPO and dwarfs Twitter’s $24.48 billion listing.
What is it about the company that makes it so attractive?
IG: In a period where tech companies are often criticised for failing to convert large user bases into profit, Alibaba has bucked the trend by showing clear earning potential. In the last fiscal year, Alibaba nearly tripled its profits to $3.75 billion, and increased its revenue 50%, to $8.45 billion. And since China’s internet penetration is not as high as in other countries, there’s still plenty of room for it to grow.
Plus, the numbers surrounding the company are staggering. In 2013, it saw sales of almost $250 billion across all of its sites, more than Amazon and eBay put together and a 45% increase on the figure for 2012.
How does the IG grey market compare with other current Alibaba valuations?
IG: In July, Alibaba updated its valuation to $130 billion, from an initial valuation of around $117 billion. A recent survey of analysts at Bloomberg valued the company at $154 billion, though that was based on the premise that the company may price its IPO beneath its assessed value to entice investors. The analysts believed that the company’s true value was $198 billion, which is more in line with IG’s grey market.
Are there any other factors behind the high level of optimism around the Alibaba IPO?
IG: US markets have seen increased volatility in recent weeks, but the S&P 500 is still 5% higher for the year, even if the Dow has given up the gains it has made. The Dow Jones and S&P 500 have both hit record highs and the Nasdaq has been trading at levels not seen since 2000. US economic data has been strong for a few months as well, so the environment remains relatively supportive for IPOs.
Is the optimism justified?
IG: Yes and no. Alibaba’s financials are strong, its revenue is comparable to that of Facebook, and profits for the year up to 31 March were around 78% higher. As such, Alibaba arrives on the markets with its earnings ability proven and with clear room for growth. However, the multitude of tech IPOs in the current market and a few unanswered questions surrounding Alibaba’s management and strategy could hold the IPO back while there is always the possibility that the company’s growth could falter, leaving investors disappointed with performance.
Are the indications that Alibaba could be the biggest ever listing?
IG: The current holder of that title is Facebook Inc (NASDAQ:FB), who listed at a value of $105 billion in 2012. It seems possible that Alibaba will take that title when it lists raising up to $20 billion putting it ahead of recent offerings such as Visa Inc (NYSE:V) in 2008 and General Motors Company (NYSE:GM) in 2010, but below that raised by the Agricultural Bank Of China Limited (HKG:1288) in 2010.
Are there any suggestions that the grey market has over-valued Alibaba?
IG: Alibaba would trade at around 54 times its earnings, which places it healthily against comparative sites like Amazon.com, Inc. (NASDAQ:AMZN) and eBay Inc (NASDAQ:EBAY). In truth, though, that is because the companies have vastly different business models, which makes western traders attempts to value Alibaba more difficult. IPOs can overvalue a company, as has arguably happened with a number of IPOs this year, but compared to some that have sold shares Alibaba seems a much more solid proposition.
Are grey markets always accurate?
IG: No, but they can often reach a level that is close to the actual value by the end of the first day of trading. In 2014 so far, grey markets have been 16% away from the exact launch figure. And that figure includes two IPOs that surprised the markets: Weibo Corp (ADR) (NASDAQ:WB) and Just Eat. Weibo dropped their IPO price at the last minute dramatically, which hugely cut the valuation of the company; Just Eat was a surprising success, launch 26% higher than the grey market.
Full list of IG’s grey market launch prices and recent IPOs: http://www.ig.com/uk/ipo-list
How does the IG grey market for Alibaba compare with those the company has conducted for Facebook, Twitter and other big flotations?
IG’s grey market was strong for Facebook, with a $97 billion estimate of its value that was just 8% off of its actual launch price. Twitter and Royal Mail, however, both surprised the markets with their stunning success. As such, IG’s valuation of both companies was well below the actual launch value.
What are the risk factors associated with the Alibaba IPO?
IG: The value of a company by the end of its first day trading on the markets is dependent on a huge variety of factors, including trader sentiment, pricing decisions from management, currency and market forces, or even geopolitical risk. Predicting value means understanding and negotiating these risks, but they can never really be negated. There is also the unexpected – the start of trading in Facebook was delayed on the day by technical problems on the exchange that did much to dampen enthusiasm for the shares.
Recent tech IPOs have been disappointing, what makes this one different?
IG: A combination of staggering figures, strong business model and enticing market.
Alibaba’s IPO presents an opportunity for traders to invest in a company that is proven to be profitable, in a market that is already huge and set to get bigger. That marks it apart from the recent social media IPOs, which were based on each company’s potential to earn profit from advertising rather than any actually made.
The company also has several ways of making profit; with sites offering business to business commerce (Ailbaba itself), as well as business to consumer (Tmall), and consumer to consumer (Taobao). They even have a Paypal equivalent, called Alipay (though the relationship between Alibaba and Alipay is complicated).
Read more about how IPOs have performed in 2014: http://www.ig.com/uk/shares-news/2014/07/11/ipos–it-pays-to-be-picky-17817
How have other Chinese company IPOs fared?
IG: Back in 2010, two major IPOs came from Youku (a video site) and DangDang (an e-commerce site). Youku saw huge interest from the markets, rising 161% to $33 on day one and then peaking at $60 a few months after. Since then, however, the price has dwindled, and currently sits around the $21 mark. DangDang saw similar high levels of interest that faded shortly after, though has been on the rise again in 2014, perhaps due to the hype surrounding Alibaba.
The most recent notable launch came from Weibo in April, a Chinese micro-blogging site that has earned (not entirely accurate) comparisons to Twitter. After a fairly strong IPO in which shares rose 19% to $24, the company has settled around the $20 mark, where it remains today.
Traders certainly have an appetite for Chinese IPOs, whether Alibaba can maintain interest with strong growth will be a key point of interest in the next months.
What lies behind the remarkable rise of Alibaba?
IG: Jack Ma. The story of the former lecturer who founded China’s first internet based company in 1995, then Alibaba in 1999, is often repeated. The entrepreneur is the guiding hand and public face of the company, allowing them to take advantage of the rise of the internet in China and become the powerhouse that they are today.
What are the company’s prospects post flotation?
IG: Alibaba is the biggest e-commerce company – 85% of China’s e-commerce activity takes place on one of its sites – in a country where internet penetration is growing each year but has not yet hit 50%. If it can demonstrate strong financials then investors may well pile on board, driving the company’s market cap upwards: comparative companies Amazon and Ebay are both currently trading at hugely inflated levels.
However, rivals in China like JD.com are now beginning to present real competition to Alibaba. There is also a degree of confusion surrounding the company’s business model and strategy, which when combined with its position in an already exotic market may lead to caution from investors. There are several potentials problems for Ma and his business to navigate if they are to truly succeed on the US market.
IG is a global leader in online trading, providing fast and flexible access to over 10,000 financial markets – including shares, indices, forex, commodities and binaries.
Established in 1974 as the world’s first financial spread betting firm, its aim is to become the default choice for active traders globally. It is already an award-winning multi-platform trading company, the world’s No.1 provider of CFDs* and a global leader in forex, and will be launching its new execution-only stockbroking service in Autumn 2014.
It is a member of the FTSE 250, with offices across Europe, Africa, Asia-Pacific and the US, where it offers limited risk derivatives contracts via the Nadex brand.
* Based on revenue excluding FX, published financial statements, July 2014.
Spread bets and CFDs are leveraged products. Spread betting and CFD trading may not be suitable for everyone and can result in losses that exceed your deposits, so please ensure that you fully understand the risks involved.
This information has been prepared by IG, a trading name of IG Markets Limited. The material on this page does not contain a record of our trading prices, or an offer of, or solicitation for, a transaction in any financial instrument. IG accepts no responsibility for any use that may be made of these comments and for any consequences that result. No representation or warranty is given as to the accuracy or completeness of this information. Consequently any person acting on it does so entirely at their own risk. Any research provided does not have regard to the specific investment objectives, financial situation and needs of any specific person who may receive it. It has not been prepared in accordance with legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and as such is considered to be a marketing communication. Although we are not specifically constrained from dealing ahead of our recommendations we do not seek to take advantage of them before they are provided to our clients.