The Big Con by David Merkel, CFA of the Aleph Blog
This is an unusual book for me to review. This is a book about Confidence Men, first published in 1940, and recently republished in 1999. It was written by David W. Maurer, who was a professor of linguistics, and used his skills to analyze the slang of the underworld.
The Big Con deals with Con Men — men who try to gain the confidence of another man in order to get him to hand over money to them.
I have often said, and many grifters would agree, that it is very hard to cheat an honest man. Honest men know that there are no easy pickings in life, and if there are some holes in the system, no one will share them with you for free. Grifters trick those who think that the world is unfair, and want to be cut in on the inside action.
This hedge fund is so optimistic about COVID-19 that they’re short Clorox [In-Depth]
A lot has happened since the coronavirus pandemic began, but aside from the temporary selloff in March, the stock market has continued to hum along as if nothing has been happening. There's no denying that the financial markets have been changed by the pandemic, and investors should be thinking differently when it comes to investing Read More
Sam Israel was tricked in that way in the book “Octopus.” Clever actors convinced him that there was easy money to be made, and they milked him and his hedge fund clients, while he lost it all.
The Big Con takes you through the human systems that con men create in order to convince their targets that they can make easy money, until the con men fleece them. The two key characters are ropers, who attract victims, and the insiderman, who is the boss and is the one who directs the whole scam.
They design a system that delivers a few small wins to the victim, who gets greedy and puts up a lot of money, and then the rigged system delivers a loss, cheating him of his money. Mot often, since the victim was an willing participant in an illegal scheme, even though he was cheated, he will not be willing to press charges, even though was cheated, because he wants to protect his reputation.
The Big Con describes the many players involved as actors, to make the enterprise look legitimate. It also describes the games that they played, and how they would entice a victim into an unfair scheme in which they would profit off others, but end up cheating the victim. The book talks about how the justice system was often bought by the insiderman, thus protecting the activities of those he employed.
It also describes how the ropers would figure out whether a victim would go along with a scam or not. It gives the history of confidence games — how they developed, and how some faded, and others grew, at least for a time.
Along with all of that, it describes the lives of the grifters, and how few of them truly prospered. Most wasted the money that they earned in riotous living. As Proverbs 13:11 says, “Wealth obtained by fraud dwindles, But the one who gathers by labor increases it.” [NASB]
To the Modern Era
Breaking from the book review, is our era so much different, or do we have the same problems in different ways?
I’ve been down enough roads in the investing world to know that there are a lot of parties who try to get people to take bad deals. It can be as simple as guys who use the “straight-line” pitch to get people to invest with them. It can be institutional investors who try to trick naive institutions.
It can be seminars with shills and other accomplices like Rich Dad and their ilk. We still have Nigerian Scams and other Scams on the Internet, many of which involve identity theft. We have promoted penny stocks, structured notes, and Ponzi schemes. I have written about all of these. Is the current era less prone to con men than the era from 1890-1940?
I would argue no, though it was more colorful and personal in the past. Today’s scams are more virtual and anonymous, leaving aside Madoff’s Ponzi Scheme which was highly personal, and psychologically design to harvest money from those that wanted a high yield with safety.
Why you should consider this book
By reading about all of the ways that people get cheated, you will be deterred from greed, and distrust those who incite greed. These problems are alive and well today. Can you learn that there are no free lunches, and no free money? If you can learn that, you are well on the way to not being cheated.
The book is repetitive. It does not condemn the grifters for the sins they commit against others. The book is almost amoral. At least, it posits a human morality, where there is a code of honor among thieves, but thievery is not in itself wrong if the victim is a greedy person.
This is a classic book that if you read it should make you more skeptical about “sure things,” and “get-rich-quick schemes.” Away from that, it is a commentary on the human condition, showing how many men are willing to compromise their ethics in order to make a lot of money. Anyway, if you want to, you can buy it here: The Big Con: The Story of the Confidence Man. It’s not expensive for what you get, and it is a colorful book.
Full disclosure: I bought a copy with my own money.
If you enter Amazon through my site, and you buy anything, I get a small commission. This is my main source of blog revenue. I prefer this to a “tip jar” because I want you to get something you want, rather than merely giving me a tip. Book reviews take time, particularly with the reading, which most book reviewers don’t do in full, and I typically do. (When I don’t, I mention that I scanned the book. Also, I never use the data that the PR flacks send out.)
Most people buying at Amazon do not enter via a referring website. Thus Amazon builds an extra 1-3% into the prices to all buyers to compensate for the commissions given to the minority that come through referring sites. Whether you buy at Amazon directly or enter via my site, your prices don’t change.