NQ Mobile Inc (NQ) Admits Widespread Data Tampering: Muddy Waters

NQ Mobile

Muddy Waters’ Carson Block is back with NQ Mobile Inc (ADR) (NYSE:NQ)’s press release in which he states the company admits that it tampered with data during the investigation.

NQ Mobile’s press release

NQ Mobile Inc (ADR) (NYSE:NQ) admitted widespread tampering with data reviewed during the investigation.  The press release reads:

“Despite the Investigation Team’s extensive review of documents and data provided by sources both within and outside the Company, the Investigation Team could not verify that the devices it collected and copied contained all responsive information at the time the copies were made. On many devices, the Investigation Team observed indications that some information might be missing, and the Company’s management and staff were unable to provide a credible explanation for what the Investigation Team observed.”

Sino-Forest’s final report

This disclosure is reminiscent of the final report delivered by Sino-Forest Corporation (TSE:TRE) (OTCMKTS:SNOFF)’s “independent” committee. The Sino-Forest directors’ conclusion was that they could find no evidence to support Muddy Waters’s fraud allegations. Sino-Forest’s exculpatory press release read:

“The Independent Committee report verifies the Company’s stated cash balances, confirms registered title or contractual rights to the Company’s stated timber assets, as well as the book value of these assets, reconciles reported total revenue and refutes the allegation that Yuda Wood is a subsidiary of the Company. We can categorically say Sino-Forest is not the ‘near total fraud’ and ‘Ponzi scheme’ as alleged by Muddy Waters.”

With a couple of name substitutions, the above statement would mirror that put out by NQ Mobile Inc (ADR) (NYSE:NQ). Unlike NQ Mobile, Sino-Forest did release a redacted version of the directors’ report. That report alluded to the evidence tampering that Sino-Forest management undertook, which appears similar to that undertaken by NQ Mobile. It cited problems, including:

  • “data on some servers in China appearing to have been deleted on an irregular basis, and there is no back-up system;”
  • “lack of full cooperation/openness in the ICs examination from certain members of Management.”

The Sino-Forest committee’s conclusion that it could find no evidence of fraud has now been thoroughly discredited. The Ontario Securities Commission is suing the former management for fraud. Just two weeks ago, Sino-Forest Corporation (TSE:TRE) (OTCMKTS:SNOFF)’s creditors filed suit against its former chairman Allen Chan for $3 billion. In the complaint (available to download here), the plaintiff dismisses the independent directors’ conclusion, and cites the data tampering as evidence of fraud. It is a sad commentary on how insulated corporate directors are from responsibility that they can publicly conclude there is no evidence of fraud after conducting an investigation in which management was caught defrauding the investigators.

This press release took seven and a half months to come out. Given that there was data tampering during an investigation that dragged on far longer than should have been allowed, it is clear that management was able to stay a step ahead of the investigation by changing and deleting data.

Muddy Waters offered to pay for well-regarded investigative accounting firm Plante & Moran PLLC to write an evaluation report of the investigation, which we would publish.

The committee declined the offer.

There are far more questions posed than answered by NQ Mobile Inc (ADR) (NYSE:NQ)’s press release. The admission of data tampering was undoubtedly the result of a negotiation between the advisors and the company, and which despite making it clear that the tampering was widespread, almost certainly understates the severity of the problem. Unless NQ Mobile chooses to provide the level of transparency that Sino-Forest did and release the actual report, we are unlikely to ever learn details about the tampering because the work is shrouded by attorney-client privilege.

For exclusive info on hedge funds and the latest news from value investing world at only a few dollars a month check out ValueWalk Premium right here.

Multiple people interested? Check out our new corporate plan right here (We are currently offering a major discount)



About the Author

Sheeraz Raza
Sheeraz is our COO (Chief - Operations), his primary duty is curating and editing of ValueWalk. He is main reason behind the rapid growth of the business. Sheeraz previously ran a taxation firm. He is an expert in technology, he has over 5.5 years of design, development and roll-out experience for SEO and SEM. - Email: sraza(at)valuewalk.com

1 Comment on "NQ Mobile Inc (NQ) Admits Widespread Data Tampering: Muddy Waters"

  1. geoffrey bailey | Jun 6, 2014, 11:32 am at 11:32 am |

    It turns out that most of Muddy Waters’ original accusations were proven untrue and others just unproven, so Muddy Waters is making new accusations. Yidatong was investigated and cleared. NQ has the cash and cash flows that Muddy Waters said NQ didn’t have. When a company gets audited thoroughly you will almost always find some minor issues that can be fixed with training or process improvement – I’m sure Muddy Waters was counting on that and ready to exploit it. Sprint doesn’t think NQ is a fraud. Where’s your evidence Muddy Waters? How about full disclosure? How many shares have you shorted NQ? On June 4, I bought 2000 shares NQ for $9.89 and sold 20 June 21 covered calls for $1.20.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.