Tesla Motors Inc Sales Model Supported By FTC

Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) has been under fire by auto dealers in multiple states, but not so fast, says the Federal Trade Commission. In fact, regulators at the agency say it’s actually a bad policy to keep Tesla from selling its cars directly to consumers.

FTC points to shopping methods

Regulators note that over time, consumers received more and more choices when it comes to where to shop for things. They started shopping locally in stores, but then mail order catalogs came along, followed by the Internet. People also used to hail cabs from the street, but now they can use their smartphones to get a cab or locate transportation.

Dan Loeb’s Third Point Re To Merge After Years Of Losses

Nestle Dan Loeb Daniel Loeb third point capital hedge fund manager activist investor poison pen activism Yahoo corporate governance famous investorsLast week, Third Point Re insurance, which is backed by US hedge-fund manager Daniel Loeb, said it would merge with Sirius International Insurance Group in a cash-and-stock deal worth around $788 million. The deal comes at a pivotal time for both companies. Third Point Re To Merge After Years Of Losses Early last year, reports Read More

Writing on the FTC blog, Andy Gavil, Debbie Feinstein and Marty Gaynor note that state and local regulators have been protecting auto dealerships from Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA)’s direct to consumer sales policy. They believe, however, that this is “bad policy,” and they list a few reasons.

Tesla as a disruptor

The regulators note that both consumers and businesses have benefited from an economy where both technologies and business models are able to disrupt industries. They, like others, see Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) as a potential disruptor. When this happens, anyone who feels threatened, like auto dealers, reacts by pushing lawmakers for protection.

They note that Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) sold just 22,000 of the 15 million cars sold in the U.S. last year, which they say is hardly a serious threat to already established dealers. The FTC regulators also note that back when the auto industry was just getting started, laws were passed to protect dealers from manufacturers as a way to even out the balance of power. They say that by trying to keep Tesla from selling its vehicles directly to consumers, the laws made to protect dealers are becoming protectionist rather than protecting.

Auto dealers’ complaint not relevant to Tesla

They also note that auto dealers have said that they need protection to keep from being abused. However, they don’t think this applies to Tesla Motors Inc (NASDAQ:TSLA) because it never had any independent dealers and apparently doesn’t even want any.

They also said that the way manufacturers choose to sell their products and services is “just as much a function of competition as what they sell” and that competition “ultimately provides the best protections for consumers and the best chances for new businesses to develop and succeed.”