Yesterday morning, Vanguard announced it would be dropping Msci Inc (NYSE:MSCI) as its index provider on 22 ETFs. In addition to an estimated $0.13 annualized EPS (JMP estimates) impact from this loss, investors believe Vanguard’s announcement highlighted a range of risks to MSCI including pricing risks in the ETF business, the risk that other clients could also switch e xisting ETFs away from MSCI (including BlackRock), and the potential for pricing pressure to spread to the broader index subscription business. It seems that the stock did over-react, dropping 27%, if 2013 EPS will only be $2.11 instead of $2.24 (or 5%), according to JMP.
Msci Inc (NYSE:MSCI) indicates that these ETFs represent $131 billion of AUM and that the annualized financial impact will be $24 million in both revenues and operating income or, we estimate $0.13 in annualized EPS.
Q2 Hedge Funds Resource Page Now LIVE!!! Lives, Conferences, Slides And More [UPDATED 7/6 22:21 EST]
Simply click the menu below to perform sorting functions. This page was just created on 7/1/2020 we will be updating it on a very frequent basis over the next three months (usually at LEAST daily), please come back or bookmark the page. As always we REALLY really appreciate legal letters and tips on hedge funds Read More
Focus Turns to Blackrock:
While the Vanguard news is a clear disappointment and a surprise to investors (Credit Suisse unaware of other established funds of this size transitioning index providers), Credit Suisse does not think it foreshadows a similar move by BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK), Msci Inc (NYSE:MSCI)’s largest customer (8% of 2011 revenue). BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK)’s iShares products have more of an institutional following that places a higher value on the underlying benchmark (MSCI), relative to Vanguard’s greater retail-orienation. However, with Blackrock accounting for a disproportionate amount of MSCI-linked ETF AUM, Credit Suisse expects pricing to come under pressure.
More important than the transition by Vanguard is the potential impact on MSCI’s relationship with BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK), the largest global ETF provider, and MSCI’s largest customer. Post Vanguard’s transition, analysts estimates that Blackrock will be ~9% of MSCI’s total revenue in 2013 (and likely 10%+ in 2014).
Why BlackRock May Be Different than Vanguard:
While the move by Vanguard has put focus on the stability of the relationship with BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK) MSCI’s largest customer. Vanguard markets itself as a low cost ETF and has more of a retail focus, which could make it easier to switch benchmarks. Following this announcement, BlackRock, Inc. (NYSE:BLK) made a public comment supporting the quality of MSCI indexes and acknowledging plans to deepen its partnership with the company. BlackRock’s relationship with MSCI could be used as a selling point on quality.
Two lessons for investors:
1. Companies that rely on a large chunk of their revenue from one or only several sources, are riskier. If company A depends on company B for 30% of that revenue, and something happens to that deal, Company A could be in big trouble. The more diversified the revenue stream the better.
2. This could be a buying opportunity for Msci Inc (NYSE:MSCI). We believe the market is not rational. If EPS should be down 5%, it does not make sense that the stock would drop 27%. Obviously, investors must do their due diligence and there are other factors besides the drop by Vanguard. However, this might be a good time to look at MSCI as a buy.
Disclosure: No p positions