Investors are wary about US stock multiples. But elevated valuations of high-growth stocks may be deceiving. Growth overachievers that can deliver persistent fundamental strength often make a mockery of their short-term valuations in hindsight.
Valuations are important for equity investors. However, simple price/earnings metrics don’t tell you whether a company is cheap or expensive. For that, we believe you need to study a company’s competitive positioning and business returns, and how its growth is funded. It takes a lot of fundamental work—and a long-term horizon.
Exceptionally high growth is rare—and often fleeting. So, the companies that do a great job of converting the promise of growth into the reality of growth should be worth a higher price tag than the average stock in the market.
Earnings Miss the Mark
As we’ve written in prior posts, we think that fundamental returns—or a company’s underlying profitability—are much more illuminating than earnings for identifying long-term growth companies. Our yardsticks are return on invested capital (ROIC) and return on assets (ROA), which tell us whether a company is investing intelligently to grow profits. Stocks of firms that generate an ROIC above a certain threshold, the so-called cost of capital, tend to outperform over the long term. Typically, management of these companies is putting capital to productive use and consistently reinvesting profitably for long-term growth.
Do Dreams Come True?
These overachieving companies come in different forms. Some are dreams come true or early-stage growth companies that deliver robust growth by transforming markets in unexpected ways. Some examples include Intuitive Surgical, a pioneer in robotic surgical tools, and Facebook and Alphabet Inc., both in digital advertising.
Others are firms like Starbucks and Xilinx, a leader in highly complicated integrated circuits that is enabling applications in fast-growing technology markets such as cloud computing and embedded vision. These are large, mature, well-run companies that have successfully overcome profit slowdowns in the past by re-inventing themselves to create new opportunities for faster growth. In both cases, these companies have powered through uncertainty by being nimble, creative and market defining. Service-oriented businesses, notably those in consumer, science-driven healthcare (biotech) and technology, tend to breed these quality companies.
Exceptional high-growth companies aren’t easy to value. Take Facebook, the quintessential disruptive-growth story. Over its entire five-year history as a public company, Facebook has always looked expensive relative to its present-day forecasts. But since then, the social media company has also repeatedly surpassed the market’s original forecasts for revenues, profits and earnings per share (Display).
Entering each calendar year since its IPO in 2012, Facebook traded at what seemed like unjustifiably high multiples relative to the market. Only in retrospect do we see what a bargain the stock was back then (Display). Fundamental analysis can help investors determine whether Facebook can continue its streak in the future.
No Rearview Mirrors
And that’s our main point: to succeed, investors must get comfortable with the idea that the bulk of the value a growth business creates is in front of it, not in the rearview mirror.
Successful growth investing is about understanding the achievability of forecasts. Companies with high profitability are more likely to deliver on forecasts because great businesses with less cyclicality and healthy balance sheets have more control over their destinies. And firms that don’t need to go to the market for funding have a huge advantage, particularly when interest rates are rising or capital markets are unstable.
Of course, some companies that look like overachievers may disappoint investors. For example, housing and construction companies that have solid recent track records might be vulnerable to rising interest rates. Investors become complacent because these companies’ current success is perceived to be normal rather than as the result of the extraordinary tailwind from interest rates. In cases like these, investors must be careful not to overvalue the contributions that low rates have had on fundamental performance over the past five years.
Exceptional companies also face greater competitive risk. A good business attracts formidable competition, which starts the process of the businesses’ returns moving closer to corporate averages. Investors should always be attuned to the risk that high returns could come down, especially if the health of a business is overstated by strong results that aren’t actually driven by a company’s strategies.
The Rewards of Persistence
Valuations are a relative concept. Not all stocks with low valuations are cheap, because some companies have lousy businesses. Similarly, not all stocks with high valuations are expensive, if they are businesses with exceptional growth potential that isn’t well understood by the market. It can be tricky to put a valuation on overachievement. But if you can find companies that can persistently exceed expectations, today’s expensive price tag could turn out to be a bargain in disguise.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. The case study example presented is to illustrate the application of our investment philosophy and is not indicative of past or future performance of any specific AllianceBernstein L.P. product or investment advisory service.
The views expressed herein do not constitute research, investment advice or trade recommendations and do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio-management teams.
Article by Frank Caruso, Alliance Bernstein