Inflation: When Owning A 20% ROE Company Is Not Enough 

Get The Full Warren Buffett Series in PDF

Get the entire 10-part series on Warren Buffett in PDF. Save it to your desktop, read it on your tablet, or email to your colleagues

Also see

In the 1980 Berkshire Shareholder letter, Buffett refers to inflation as a tax on capital that is just as real as the explicit income tax. We are not anywhere near the inflation levels that persisted in the environment around this time, but it’s important to remember why inflation is important for every investor.

Purchasing power

As Buffett writes, “For only gains in purchasing power represent real earnings on investment.”

[drizzle]

What does this mean?

It means real earnings on investment occur when the investor has become richer. Again this is not richer in dollar terms per se, but purchasing power. The investor is richer when he or she is able to buy more. Here’s an example using hamburgers that Buffett uses that illustrates this:

“For only gains in purchasing power represent real earnings on investment. If you forego (a) ten hamburgers to purchase an investment; (b) receive dividends which, after tax, buy two hamburgers; and (c) receive, upon sale of your holdings after-tax proceeds that will buy eight hamburgers, then (d) you have had no real income from your investment, no matter how much it appreciated in dollars. You may feel richer, but you won’t eat richer.

Here is another example from Buffett from the 1980 shareholders letter, paraphrased in our own words:
Imagine inflation is running at 12% and you own a company that is earning 20% on equity. Assume that you are in the 50% tax bracket and receive all of the earnings of the business as a distributed dividend. So half of your 20% will go to income tax, leaving you with 10%. However, if inflation is 12%, your purchasing power will be eaten up, negating the remaining 10% earned from the business and decreasing your purchasing power by 2% (10% minus 12%) to 98%.

It’s amazing how powerfully (destructive) inflation can be to investor wealth. Most companies do not come close to earning 20% ROE but inflation rates have approached double digit levels multiple times throughout the past 50 years. Note in the chart below, CPI in 1980 of 14.59%.

Inflation

Inflation

[/drizzle]